herself, while the burgers sizzled. He'd been thinking about it ever since. An
accusation becomes a memory. Not a fact. Not a verdict. A memory, the kind
that lives in the body. Jordan would remember the sound of those car doors.
Mia would remember the questions. Tasha would remember standing in her
own yard feeling like a suspect.
"You know what her being here fixed?" Marcus said. "Today. It fixed today.
The officers listened because she was standing there. Karen backed down
because she was standing there. But it didn't fix the part where it happened in
84
the first place. It didn't fix the part where three cars came for burgers."
"No," Tasha said. "It didn't."
"And tomorrow she'll be gone, and it'll just be us and the street again. And
Karen. And everybody who watched from their windows." He gestured
vaguely at the dark houses. "I wonder what they're thinking tonight. The ones
who didn't come over. The ones who just watched."
Tasha was quiet a moment. "Mrs. Abernathy texted. She said she saw the
whole thing from her kitchen and she froze. She said she's ashamed she
didn't come out."
"Did she say that?"
"Word for word. She's bringing a pound cake tomorrow. She said it's an
apology cake."
Marcus smiled despite himself. "There's no such thing as an apology cake."
"There is now. She invented it." Tasha sipped her tea. "I told her it was fine.
And it is, mostly. Freezing is human. Calling 911 on a family barbecue is a
choice."
"That's the line, isn't it? Between freezing and choosing."
"That's the line."
They finished their tea and went inside, and the porch light stayed on behind
them, burning steady over an empty step.
The next morning the phone rang while Marcus was scraping the grill. He
almost didn't answer — unknown number, and after yesterday he had a new
relationship with unknown numbers — but something made him pick up.
"Marcus, it's Elaine Harris."
85
He stood there with the wire brush in one hand and grease on his forearm,
and for a second his brain refused to assemble the sentence.
"Governor — ma'am. Good morning."
"I hope I'm not calling too early."
"No, ma'am. We're up." He glanced at the house. Mia's face was pressed to
the kitchen window, watching him with enormous interest. He waved the
brush at her and she vanished, giggling.
"I've been thinking about yesterday," Harris said. "And I have a suggestion,
not an order. Karen Whitman called my office this morning. She wants —
she's asking how to make this right. I told her I couldn't answer that for your
family. But I said I'd ask if she'd be welcome to come by and speak to you
herself."
Marcus was quiet. The grill brush dripped.
"You're allowed to say no," Harris said. "Completely. No explanation
needed."
He thought about Jordan's question. He thought about Tasha's sentence —
dangerous before we were met. He thought about the look on Karen
Whitman's face yesterday when Harris had asked her, gently and without
mercy, what exactly she had reported, and the answer had been nothing.
People I don't know.
"Tell her she can come this afternoon," Marcus said. "Four o'clock. The
porch."
"Are you sure?"
"No," Marcus said honestly. "But tell her anyway."
86
Karen Whitman arrived at four o'clock exactly, driving herself, alone. She
parked across the street in front of her own house and walked over, which
Marcus found himself respecting without wanting to. She wore a plain blouse
and carried nothing. No casserole, no flowers, no props. Just herself, which
was either brave or all she had.
Tasha opened the door. For a moment the two women looked at each other
across the threshold — the woman who had called and the woman who had
been called about — and then Tasha stepped back.
"Come on in. We're on the porch."
They sat in the wicker chairs, the four of them, with a pitcher of lemonade
sweating on the table between them. Mia was drawing at the far end of the
porch, ostensibly absorbed, entirely listening. Jordan had claimed a sudden
urgent need to be in the backyard, which everyone understood to mean he
was listening from the corner of the house.
Karen folded her hands in her lap. She looked smaller than she had
yesterday. Yesterday she'd had the bright, brittle energy of a person
performing certainty. Today the performance was gone and what was left
looked tired.
"I don't really know how to start," she said. "So I'll just say it. I'm sorry. I'm
sorry I called the police on your family. I'm sorry for what I put you through.
There's no excuse. I was — " She stopped. "I told the governor I was scared,
and that's true, but scared of what? That's the question I've been asking
myself all night, and I don't have a good answer. I'd never spoken to you. I'd
never even — " Her voice thinned. "I'd only been here a month. I didn't know
anyone. And instead of introducing myself, I — " She gestured helplessly
toward the street, toward yesterday. "I'm sorry."
87
"A month," Tasha said. Not unkindly. Just placing it.
"Thirty-four days." Karen managed something like a smile. "My husband's
job moved us. He travels three weeks out of four. I work from home. I kept