actually stepped away from the curtains that day, gone into the kitchen,
looked at the drawing — the smiling sun, the too many windows — and felt
something crack open in her chest, something honest trying to get out.
But honesty, she'd learned over the years, was easier in the abstract than in
the moment. And the moment kept arriving: the unfamiliar car, the laughter,
the smoke, the crowd. And each time, the old machinery kicked in — the
stories, the warnings, her mother's voice on the phone years ago when Karen
mentioned a new neighborhood: just be careful, that's all I'm saying, you hear
things. The news on in the background for years. The faces in the stories.
The faces across the street.
It wasn't chosen. That was what she told herself, and it was true, as far as it
went. She hadn't chosen the feeling. But standing at the window, curtain in
her fist, she was choosing what to do with it. And that was the part she
wouldn't look at, not directly, not yet — the part where the feeling stopped
being something that happened to her and started being something she was
doing.
It wasn't anything she could name, which was the worst part. The house was
fine. The street was fine. The neighbors — the ones she'd met — were fine.
17
But comfort kept not arriving, like a guest who kept promising to come and
never did. She found herself noticing things. The cars she didn't recognize.
The teenagers cutting through yards. The way the quiet of the street
sometimes felt less like peace and more like something holding its breath.
And now this. This noise across the street. This crowd.
She stood at the window with the curtain pulled back just enough, a coffee
gone cold in her hand, and watched the Johnsons' backyard fill up, and she
tried — honestly tried, because Karen Whitman thought of herself as a fair
person — to interrogate the feeling item by item, the way you'd check off a
list.
The music. She listened. It was jazz, soft, barely carrying across the street.
Not loud. Not a problem.
The number of people. She counted. Eight, nine. A handful. A family
cookout. People had family cookouts.
The children. They were shrieking, yes, but they were children, and children
were everywhere, and children shrieked. That was what children did. She had
been a child. She had shrieked.
The barbecue itself. Smoke rose from a grill. Everyone grilled. Half the street
grilled on Saturdays. The Hendersons grilled. She had smelled their burgers
last week and thought it smelled wonderful.
None of it explained the feeling. That was the terrible part — she could find
nothing wrong, and the feeling stayed anyway, sitting low in her stomach
like something she'd swallowed that wouldn't digest.
What bothered her was not on the list. What bothered her was underneath the
list, older than the list, and she knew it even as she refused to look directly at
18
it. It was the unease she had been handed years ago, in pieces, by people who
loved her and meant well: the warnings, the stories, the assumptions passed
down like furniture. Be careful. Lock the doors. You never know. The faces
in the stories had always looked a certain way, and the faces across the street
looked that way too, and the feeling had arrived before the facts, the way it
always did, the way it had been trained to do.
She was not a hateful woman. If you had asked her — if anyone had ever
asked her directly — she would have told you, sincerely, that she judged
people as individuals. She had Black colleagues. She had been perfectly
pleasant to the cashier. She did not think of herself as the kind of person who
felt what she was feeling, which made the feeling worse, because now there
was the feeling and also the shame of the feeling, and the shame made her
defensive, and the defensiveness needed somewhere to go.
So it went to the Johnsons. It went to the laughter, which started to sound, in
her head, like too much laughter. It went to the cars in the driveway — one
she didn't recognize, which must belong to someone, which meant someone
she didn't know was over there. It went to the smoke, which was just smoke,
but which she watched as if it might be evidence of something.
She tried to shake it off. She actually turned from the window at one point,
walked into the kitchen, ran water over her cold coffee, told herself out loud,
"Karen, stop it. It's a barbecue." She stood at the sink and breathed and
listened to the faint jazz and the children's shrieks, and for a moment the
feeling loosened, like a knot easing.
Then a fresh burst of laughter rolled across the street — big, unrestrained,
Marcus's laugh, the kind that started in the chest — and the knot pulled tight
again, tighter than before, as if the feeling were angry at being questioned.
19
She went back to the window.
This was the pattern of the afternoon: the watching, the justifying, the
almost-leaving, the return. Each time she came back to the curtains, the
feeling had a new reason ready, rehearsed like a speech. It was the noise —
well, not the noise exactly, but the principle of the noise. It was the crowd —