people who will tell you you're overreacting right up until the moment you're
proven right. Karen had grown up on those sentences the way other children
grow up on lullabies. Lock the car doors the second you sit down. Don't walk
past a group of men on the sidewalk — cross the street, it's not rude, it's
smart. If something feels off, it is off. The feeling is the evidence.
She had never once interrogated the feeling. It had never occurred to her that
a gut could be trained the way a dog is trained — on scraps, on repetition, on
everything it had ever been fed. She stood at the window and watched a little
girl do a victory dance around a cooler, and she told herself the unease in her
stomach was instinct, and she did not ask herself where the instinct had
learned its manners.
Twice she picked up the phone to call back and cancel it. Twice she set it
down again. To cancel would be to admit the call had been a mistake, and
Karen Whitman, forty-one years old, less than a month in a new
26
neighborhood, did not make mistakes about things like this. She had been
sure. She was still sure — wasn't she? The certainty had a strange texture
now, smooth on top and hollow underneath, like ice over moving water. She
pressed her forehead harder into the curtain and waited for the sound she had
summoned.
Minutes passed. That was the worst part, the minutes. The balloons bobbed.
A broad man she didn't know carried a tray of corn from the grill to the table,
laughing at something a woman said. The children chased each other around
the cooler by the back door, shrieking, and Mia — the little girl with the
blunt funny face — did a victory dance that made two adults double over. It
looked, Karen thought with a lurch low in her gut, like a picture from a
magazine. It looked like happiness, complete and unbothered, and the fact
that it looked like happiness made her angrier, because if it was happiness
then what had she just done? What had she set in motion?
She thought about calling back. The thought came and went like a car
passing — she watched it go. To call back would be to say she'd made a
mistake. She didn't make mistakes about things like this. Her mother had
always said: trust your gut. Her gut had never been wrong. Her gut was
churning acid.
Then she heard it. Faint at first, the way a headache starts behind one eye —
a siren, far off, threading through the Saturday afternoon, weaving between
the subdivisions. Karen's breath caught. This was real now, undeniably real,
no longer a phone call she could hang up on but a sound moving through the
world toward her street, toward the house across from hers. She had the
sudden wild urge to run outside and wave the cruisers off, to tell them never
mind, false alarm, everything's fine — but her feet stayed planted on the rug,
and the urge passed, and what replaced it was a strange, hollow steadiness:
27
whatever happened next, she had set it in motion, and she would watch it
arrive.
It grew. It turned, unmistakably, toward Willow Creek Drive, the wail
dopplering down into the street's name like it had been addressed there
personally.
Karen's hands tightened on the sill until her knuckles went white. This was
the moment she'd been waiting for — vindication approaching with flashing
lights — and instead of relief she felt something cold spreading outward
from her sternum. What if they found nothing? The thought arrived uninvited
and she shoved it away, but it came back, patient as tide: what if they found
nothing but a family, and the nothing was the point, and everyone on this
street would know by dinner whose call had brought three cruisers to a
barbecue?
She almost hoped, suddenly and fiercely, that the officers would find
something — a fight, a weapon, anything — just so the call would have been
justified. The hope shamed her even as she felt it. She pressed her forehead
to the glass and watched the red and blue wash over Marcus Johnson's lawn,
over his table, over his children's upturned faces, and she told herself, one
more time, that she'd done the right thing. The words had gone thin now,
almost transparent. She could see through them to whatever was underneath,
and she chose, deliberately, not to look.
The first cruiser came around the bend at the end of the street with its light
bar flashing — siren cut now, which somehow made it worse, the silent red
and blue strobing across the trimmed hedges and the mailboxes and the faces
turning toward it. Then a second cruiser. Then a third. Three patrol cars, one
after another, rolling down Willow Creek Drive in procession, and every
head at the Johnsons' party turned at once, the way a field of sunflowers
28
turns.
The jazz kept playing. That was the strangest part — Karen would think
about it for months afterward, the detail that stayed. The music didn't stop. It
just suddenly became very loud in the new silence, a saxophone curling
through the air over a backyard full of frozen people, obscenely cheerful.