A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"This is not about one man's worst minute," he said. "I want to say that before you see anything, and I want to say it again after. This is about a pattern that people in Westbrook have been describing, in this room and in rooms like it, for a long time, and that until now existed only in their word against a uniform. Today it exists on video, because we were documenting it when it happened to us. But the people you will hear from did not have cameras pointed the right way. That does not make what happened to them less real."

Kelvin, seated in the front row with his notebook closed on his knee, kept his eyes on the audience rather than the screen. He had watched the footage perhaps forty times in the editing — if you could call it editing, because they had decided, after long argument late into two nights, to change almost nothing. No music. No slow motion. No captions beyond names, dates, and the words body camera, chest recorder, witness phone where the angle changed. Let the cuts between perspectives do the work. Let people hear the park: the river beyond the trees, a dog barking far off, the ordinary sound of an afternoon that had not asked to become evidence. Kelvin had argued that any polish would be read as manipulation. Damon had agreed, and still worried that rawness would be read as cruelty, as if they had wanted Officer Ryan Caldwell to look as bad as he did. They had not wanted that. They had wanted a record. The record, it turned out, needed no help.

When Damon nodded, Helen dimmed the lights at the back, and Riverside Park filled the white wall.

There they were, himself and Kelvin on the bench, notebooks open, the black duffel between Kelvin's feet. There was the approach, too quick, the voice already raised before a question had been fully asked. There was the demand to stand, to produce identification, to explain what they were doing in a public park in daylight as if presence required explanation. There was Kelvin, calm to the point that some viewers would later mistake it for provocation, saying they were working, that they were not required to move, that the bag could be described but not surrendered without cause. And there was the moment that had already, in the forty-eight hours since the department had confirmed an internal review, become a rumor looking for a picture: Ryan Caldwell, twenty-six, drawing his taser and aiming it at two unarmed men who remained seated, whose hands were visible, whose voices — this was what struck the room most, Damon could feel it in the silence behind him — never rose to meet his.

On the screen, his own voice said, clearly, without triumph, "Make sure your camera catches this part."

Someone in the third row exhaled as if she had been holding her breath for someone else. Rosa Jimenez, who sat with her daughter's hand tight in hers, looked down. She had consented to have her name and her account included in the packet the Project was releasing that day, and she had insisted on being present, but consent, Damon understood, did not make watching any easier. Beside her, Walter Greene sat very straight, as a man who had once worn a different uniform and still carried himself by its habits, his cane resting against his chair. Jamal Ortiz was not there — at seventeen, his mother had decided the cameras were too much, and the Project had honored that without persuasion — but his written statement was in the packet, and his absence was itself a kind of statement that Damon hoped reporters would respect. Tanya Brooks sat near the aisle with her sister, her youngest asleep against her shoulder, and did not look away from the screen at all.

The footage ran seven minutes and twelve seconds in its longest version. They showed it once, all the way through, without stopping for commentary. The bodycam angle was the worst, because it placed the viewer behind Caldwell's own shoulder, inside his escalation; you heard his breathing. You heard Sergeant Tom Reilly arrive late in the sequence, heard the change when a supervisor's voice entered and the order to release them was given, flat and urgent, as if Reilly had understood in an instant what the lenses all around him were already preserving. The taser lowered. It did not disappear from memory because it lowered.

When the lights came up, no one applauded. Damon was grateful for that. He read the names aloud — Jamal Ortiz, Walter Greene, Rosa Jimenez, Tanya Brooks — and the dates attached to each account, and explained, with Helen beside him now, what consent had meant in practical terms: each person had reviewed their own statement, each had been told they could withdraw up to the moment of release, each had been told, plainly, that attention was not the same as protection and that the Project could not promise what would follow. "They said yes anyway," Helen said, in the even voice that had made her, over years of contentious meetings, the person both sides asked to hold the microphone. "You should understand what that cost them to say."

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

30 Part