A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

No one made a sound while it played. Damon watched Kelvin become extremely still, except for one muscle in his cheek. When the red dot moved from Damon to Kelvin and back, Kelvin's hands pressed down a fraction harder on the table. Damon remembered thinking at the time about the bench's wood against the backs of his thighs, one slat warmer than the others, and wondering whether standing slowly would read as compliance or as movement — and movement, he had understood with his whole animal body, could be narrated afterward as anything. So he had not moved. They had not moved. The footage ended not with a shot but with a supervisor's voice arriving off camera, and Caldwell lowering the taser with a jerk, as if he himself had only just heard how loud the moment had become.

Kelvin testified that afternoon, after a lunch most people had not really eaten. He was thirty-two, leaner than Damon, funnier than Damon in ordinary life, and none of that was available to him at the witness table. He spoke about systems, because that was how his mind protected him: the chest recorder, where its files were stored, the chain of custody maintained hour by hour afterward, the copy never edited because, he said, "the whole point of what we do is that we don't get to edit." Asked if he had been afraid, he said respectability entered these proceedings through the side door — as if their fear needed to be certified tasteful — and then answered anyway. Yes. Afraid in his body and angry in his mind at the same time, and the two had not canceled each other. He had thought of his sister, who had warned him this work would get him in trouble in a tone that meant get him killed. He had kept his hands on his knees because Damon had. "I trusted his judgment about not moving," he said. "That's all."

Jamal Ortiz went first, seventeen, in a buttoned shirt his mother had clearly insisted on, his bicycle helmet carried in because he had ridden there. A year earlier, Caldwell had stopped him two blocks from school because, Caldwell said, his bicycle matched one reported taken. It did not, in color or make, as the department's own log later showed. He had been ordered off the bike, searched against a fence while two friends watched, his backpack emptied onto the pavement — a calculator, a paperback, a sandwich arranged, for a long minute, like evidence. No stolen bicycle was ever connected to him. He was released with a warning to cooperate faster next time. "I did cooperate," Jamal said, his voice cracking, not from tears but from the treachery of being seventeen. His mother put her hand flat between his shoulder blades. "I just cooperated slow because I was scared. I didn't know slow counted as something."

Walter Greene was sixty-eight, a veteran who wore that word without display — a faded cap he removed indoors unasked. Caldwell had ordered him off a bench near the river path the previous autumn for loitering, in a park, in daylight, where he sat most afternoons since his wife's death because the house was too quiet at that hour and the river was not. When Greene asked, with elaborate politeness, what law he was breaking, Caldwell stood closer than he needed to and said a bench was for people passing through, not camping, and he could move along or have the conversation downtown. Greene moved along. Trained long ago, in a very different uniform, to obey lawful orders and recognize unlawful ones, he still carried the humiliation of having obeyed an unlawful one in front of a granddaughter bringing him coffee. "She's nine," he said. "She asked me why I let him talk to me like that. I did not have an answer that I liked."

Rosa Jimenez testified through an interpreter, though her English, as she noted with dry precision, was entirely sufficient for selling tamales and sweet corn, which she had done from a licensed cart near the park entrance for eleven seasons. Her cart had been searched — the word she used was opened, everything opened — because Caldwell claimed a complaint about unpermitted food handling and because she had produced her permit too slowly, from the wrong pocket, while a line waited. Nothing was found out of order. Three customers left. She lost an afternoon's earnings and, more durably, the feeling she had built over a decade that her papers protected her in proportion to how completely she kept them in order. "I keep them laminated now," she said, producing the permit to a ripple of sad laughter. "Laminated is not a law. But I do it anyway."

Tanya Brooks, a mother of two who worked nights cleaning surgical suites, described being stopped in her car with her four-year-old asleep in the back seat, because Caldwell said she had rolled a stop sign she was certain — and a neighbor's doorbell camera later confirmed — she had fully stopped at. He kept her forty minutes, asked where she was coming from as if the answer were a test, asked who the child belonged to, asked her to step out while the child slept, so that when she complied and the door chime sounded, the little girl woke alone behind glass and began, in that stop's bodycam audio, to cry in a way that made several people look at their laps. No citation was issued. She was told attitude made stops longer. "My attitude," she told the board, "was that my daughter needed to use the bathroom and I needed to get to work. I said please eleven times. I counted later, on the recording. Eleven."

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

30 Part