Damon Wright sat at the witness table and tried not to look at the screen. It had been wheeled in that morning, a large monitor on a stand, its black face reflecting the room back at itself, and he knew what would happen when they turned it on. He had watched the footage more times than he had admitted to anyone, including Kelvin — at his kitchen table at two in the morning, sound off, then on, hand over the spacebar, as if stopping it earlier in his living room might stop it earlier in the park. It did not get easier. It got more precise. He could anticipate the exact second his own voice changed.
Kelvin Miles sat beside him with his hands folded so tightly his knuckles had gone pale, then deliberately laid them flat, palms down, as he had taught himself to do in interviews when he needed a source to believe he was not in a hurry. Kelvin had been an investigator with the Westbrook Accountability Project for four years, Damon for six, and they had sat in rooms like this as observers so often they had a private language of glances — this one is lying, this one is scared, this one has already decided. Now they were not observers. Nameplates said their names. A court reporter flexed her fingers. Neither man drank from the glasses of water set before them.
Helen Park called the room to order in a voice that was not loud and did not need to be. She explained the purpose of the proceeding, and its limits, and its powers, which were still the old powers — to hear, to recommend, to publish — and said plainly that what happened here would become part of a public record. She did not thank the department for its cooperation, and the omission was noticed in the way omissions in careful speeches always are. Lieutenant Karen Doyle, in uniform in the second row, kept her face still. Chief Alan Mercer, beside her, folded his program in half and then unfolded it again.
When Damon was sworn in, he felt the boyish urge to make his voice steadier than it was, and resisted it. He gave his name, his age — thirty-four — his occupation. He described the Westbrook Accountability Project in grant-report terms: an independent effort that recorded police encounters in public spaces in the Westbrook District, maintained an archive, and referred people who asked for help to legal aid. He described Thursday in late April, in order, without decorating it. They had gone to Riverside Park because complaints from that quadrant had crossed a threshold in their intake log — three in two weeks, all describing prolonged detentions of people never charged. The black duffel held, and he listed its contents as he would have listed groceries, only a lawful documentation kit: charged batteries, a canvas-covered notebook, printed copies of the city's filming-in-public guidance, a small tripod, water, and Kelvin's chest recorder in its harness. They had sat on the weathered bench near the cottonwoods for forty minutes, and had filmed nothing except, once, a heron.
A board member asked what happened next, though everyone knew. Damon said an officer approached: Officer Ryan Caldwell, twenty-six, Westbrook District. Being asked what they were doing, and answering. Being asked for identification they were not legally required to provide, and declining, politely, while continuing to record, as was their right. Being told the duffel was suspicious. Being told to stand. He paused, not for effect, but because the next part lived in his body in a way chronology did not. His hands had stayed where they could be seen, on his knees. Kelvin's had done the same. They were seated. They remained seated.
"And then?" Helen Park said, gently.
"And then he drew his taser and aimed it at us," Damon said. "At me first. Then at both of us."
"I said, 'Make sure your camera catches this part,'" he said. "I said it to Kelvin. It wasn't brave. I wanted there to be a record that would survive whatever happened in the next minute. I thought if my voice was calm on the recording, someone later would understand that we weren't a threat. That we were just sitting there, and a man was pointing a weapon at us for it."
The footage was played after the recess. There were, counsel explained for the record, three recordings, shown in sequence and synced where possible: the officer's bodycam, Kelvin's chest recorder, and a witness phone video taken by a woman walking her dog, who had asked, understandably, not to be in the room while it played. The screen brightened. The black mirror became a park.
Bodycam footage has a particular cruelty: it shows the world from the center of the chest of the person holding the power, so everyone else appears to be approaching him, looming, even when they have not moved at all. And still, even with that distortion working in Caldwell's favor, what the room saw was unmistakable. Two men on a bench. A duffel on the ground, zipped, untouched. Hands visible. Voices level, then tighter. The taser's housing entering the bottom of the frame, the red dot finding Damon's shirt and trembling there. On Kelvin's recorder the angle reversed, and the room saw Caldwell as the park had seen him: young, jaw set, shoulders high, breathing too fast, repeating an order he seemed to be trying to convince himself was lawful. On the phone video, shaky with the filmer's fear, the tableau shrank to its true proportions: a bench, two seated men, a standing officer, a weapon, and around them the ordinary park continuing — a jogger slowing, a child on a scooter stopping at a father's hand.