A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Afternoon," he said.

Both men looked up then, because not to look up now would be its own statement, and gave him the full, calm attention of people who had decided in advance to give it. Damon met his eyes without challenge and without submission, a look that simply registered him — young, uniformed, camera blinking red on his chest like a second, smaller eye. Kelvin nodded once, politely, the nod of a man acknowledging anyone whose job brought them briefly into the orbit of his afternoon.

"Afternoon, Officer," Damon said. His voice was even and carried no further than the bench, by design. Behind the playground fence a child laughed with a volume that suggested whatever was funny had been very funny indeed.

Caldwell had expected some immediate signal, in one direction or the other. Guilt hurried to fill a silence, in his experience; innocence, in the stories he told himself, was supposed to be relaxed and forthcoming. What he got was composure so complete it registered as a surface he could not read, and unreadability, to a young officer with the sun in his face, felt remarkably like resistance. His jaw set a fraction. The red light on his chest blinked, and he took strength from it in a direction he did not examine: the camera would see his courtesy, he thought, and their evasion.

"How long have you two been sitting here?" he asked. It was not the opening he had rehearsed — in the cruiser the opening had been a pleasantry about the weather that established command by seeming not to. In the actual air between them the pleasantry had seemed too transparent, and he had reached instead for a direct question, and the directness now hung there, demanding to be justified by the answers it got.

Damon considered the question precisely, and for what it presumed. It presumed a duration could be suspicious. It presumed an accounting was owed. He answered honestly and no more than honestly, because honesty, carefully rationed, is also a discipline. "A while," he said. "It's a nice day for it."

"A while," Caldwell repeated, with a small, humorless smile. "Hour? Two hours? I watched you, and in that time I haven't seen you do much of anything. No phones out. No food. Just sitting, in a park, middle of a workday. So I'll ask it plain, so we can clear it up: what are you doing here?"

Kelvin felt the question land with the weight of all the times some version of it had been transcribed into the project's notebooks. What are you doing here. Not is everything all right, not can I help you. The grammar of belonging revoked, pending a satisfactory answer. He glanced at Damon — not for permission, they'd settled that order of things long before, in a room with a whiteboard and bad coffee, but in acknowledgment, the way a musician glances at another before a familiar passage — and Damon answered, because his voice, when a moment called for one voice, had the ballast.

"We're enjoying the park," Damon said. "Same as everyone else here, I'd say."

"Enjoying the park," Caldwell said.

"Yes, sir." The sir cost Damon nothing and he gave it freely; courtesy, in his filing system, was not submission, it was a tool left visible on the table for the record. It did not have the hoped-for effect. Courtesy from a man Caldwell had already decided was evasive read as polish, and polish read as practice, and practice read as something practiced for a reason. He shifted his weight, resettling his belt with a thumb.

"You live around here?" he asked.

"We live in Westbrook," Damon said.

"That's not what I asked. I asked if you live around here. Near the park."

"We're in the park," Kelvin said quietly, and then, because he could hear how even that mild sentence might be sharpened by someone determined to sharpen it, he softened it with an addition that was also true. "We came down for the afternoon."

Caldwell's attention snapped to Kelvin with the quickness of a man who has been waiting for the quieter one to speak, because in his training and in his temperament the second voice was where stories came apart. "And you are?" he asked. "Both of you. Let's start with names, since we're all just enjoying the park together."

There was a pause — not long, not theatrical, but real — in which the two seated men exchanged no look at all, and the absence of the look was itself a communication Caldwell felt excluded from and resented. They had prepared for this question in the church basement and the laundromat office, with a lawyer from the legal aid clinic who had written three sentences on a whiteboard and underlined the third twice. You are not required to produce identification on demand in a consensual encounter, and an encounter stays consensual only as long as you are free to leave it — which is precisely what such questions, asked in such a tone, are designed to make you doubt. Damon knew the law as terrain he actually lived in. He also knew, with his whole body, that reciting the law to a young officer on a spring afternoon was an act the law itself could not protect him from. Both knowledges sat in him at once, and held.

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

30 Part