A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The community meetings, by then, had become Westbrook arguing with itself in rooms too small for its feelings. At the library, a man who coached Little League and had known Caldwell since the boy bagged groceries at the market on Fifth stood to say that everyone in the room had once been grateful for a fast response and that a good kid was being destroyed by a video edited by activists with an agenda, and the room did not boo him; Westbrook, to its credit and its torment, listened, because half the room had a version of the same thought and the other half knew it. At Grace Lutheran, in the same fellowship hall where the footage had first been shown, Tanya Brooks answered him without ever having heard him, standing with no notes while her sister held the baby in the back. "My children were in the car," she said. "He stopped us for a brake light that was not out. My son still asks if the police are going to be mad at our car. I am not an agenda. I'm the lady from the car wash on Merritt Street, and some of you have known me since I was a girl." Walter Greene, at the microphone after her, put it with a veteran's economy. "I defended this country. I don't need defending from a bench." And Rosa Jimenez, who had lost a Saturday's earnings to a search that found nothing and received no apology with a signature on it, said the thing that was quoted, finally, more widely than any official statement: "He did not find anything in my cart. He found out he could look. That is different, and everybody here knows it is different." No consensus emerged, because consensus was not what the meetings were for. They were for the record — a phrase Westbrook had begun, without irony, to use about its own life.

On a grey Tuesday, three weeks after the release, Helen Park stood on the steps of city hall in her capacity as chair of the civilian review board, flanked by counsel for the Project and by Damon and Kelvin, who wore, neither of them, the expression of men who thought they had won. She announced that the board would convene a formal public hearing, with subpoenaed records, sworn testimony, and a published docket, into Officer Caldwell's conduct, his supervision, and the department's complaint and sign-off practices over the preceding two years. She announced, in the next breath, that Damon Wright, Kelvin Miles, Jamal Ortiz, Walter Greene, Rosa Jimenez, and Tanya Brooks had filed a civil suit in federal court alleging a pattern and practice of unconstitutional stops and searches in the Westbrook District, and naming, among others, Ryan Caldwell, Tom Reilly, and the city. She took no questions. The wind took the edge off the microphones. That afternoon, in a one-paragraph notice delivered to Caldwell at his parents' house by a process of notification so bureaucratic it felt almost gentle, the department placed Ryan Caldwell on administrative leave, effective immediately, his badge and service weapon surrendered to a lieutenant who avoided his eyes and then, ashamed, met them. Mercer, in the department's accompanying statement, said the leave was not a finding. Doyle, reading the statement in her office, thought it was the first entirely true sentence the department had issued in weeks. Reilly, at home, received a separate letter and sat with it unopened while his phone rang. Damon, told the news by a reporter before any official channel reached him, walked out of the Project's office and down to Riverside Park, where the bench stood empty in the late light and two men he did not know were fishing from the bank, unmolested, unrecorded, ordinary. He did not sit down. Nothing had been decided. A hearing could vindicate, condemn, or, most likely, complicate every person it touched; a lawsuit could settle, stall, or fail on grounds no one in Westbrook would ever find satisfying; a young officer could tell the truth, or keep telling the thinner one, or discover that the distance between them was where the rest of his life would be lived. The river went on doing what it had done during the seven minutes that had changed the town, which was to say it went past the park without comment, carrying the light. Damon stood there until the light was gone from the water, and then he walked home through streets where people were, for the first time in his memory of them, arguing about the same facts.

The hearing room had been a cafeteria once, and it had never quite stopped smelling like one. Under the fluorescent lights there was still the faint, sweet ghost of milk cartons and floor cleaner, the tables replaced by folding chairs and a raised platform where the civilian review board sat behind nameplates printed, laminated, and slightly crookedly set. Helen Park, in the center, adjusted hers without looking at it. She had the posture of a woman who had run meetings in rooms less grand than this for thirty years and knew grandeur had nothing to do with whether anyone told the truth. People had arrived early, with notebooks and thermoses and children who were quickly hushed, until latecomers stood along the back wall with their shoulders against the paint.

News in the same category

A Rookie Cop Aimed a Taser at Two Men on a Park Bench — Then One Said, “Make Sure Your Camera Catches This Part.”

30 Part