So it was noticed, in the second week of November, when it became otherwise.
It was a small change. Reilly, watching a basics drill from the front with his arms folded, stopped the class mid-count, walked down the second line, and rearranged it with the flat of his hand: Ellis to the back, the nurse forward two places, and the new white belt, Ren, moved out of the end position altogether and set in the middle of the front line, directly under his eye, between Mags and the schoolteacher. He gave no reason. He rarely gave reasons; reasons, in his view, were a senior grade. He simply put her there, the way you move a lamp to read by, and resumed the count.
Mags understood at once, or thought she did, and was privately pleased: the girl had been picked out for encouragement, the small honour Reilly sometimes paid a promising beginner, moving them up where the work was visible. Chad, watching from the senior bench during his rest, read it differently and enjoyed it: the Little White Belt promoted to the front line, where her luck would have less room to hide in. Both of them were wrong, though Mags was nearer.
For Reilly was not watching Ren's techniques. He was watching her feet.
Thirty-one years of standing at the front of halls had given him a particular education. Hands lie, he sometimes told the senior class. Hands are vain; they learn flourishes and perform them. Faces lie constantly. But feet tell the truth, because nobody thinks to teach them to lie. A beginner's feet shuffle, hesitate, arrive late and apologise. An experienced fighter's feet are a quiet bureaucracy, filing everything in advance: weight placed before it is needed, the turn prepared two movements early, the retreat begun before the attack has finished being an idea.
Ren's feet, in the middle of the front line, doing the plainest basics in the syllabus, were doing things he had not seen in his hall in twenty years.
It was the turns that had first caught him, weeks before, at the end of a line, the weight going through the ball of the foot with a patience and precision that coaching can produce in perhaps one student in five hundred. Now, up close, he saw the rest of it: the way she set her stance a fraction deeper than the beginners and a fraction shallower than the textbook, exactly where a working stance lives; the way her back heel, in front stance, did not creep; the way, in the stepping drill, her feet never crossed, never hurried, and were never, not once in forty minutes, where a technique would have found them had anyone been sending one.
He set the class a moving drill, block and counter in pairs along the line, and walked it slowly, stopping the pairs, correcting. When he reached Ren, partnered with the schoolteacher, he stopped them for longer than the others. The schoolteacher was earnest and improving and threw her counter with her whole heart and most of her balance. Ren blocked, and stepped, and her answering touch arrived, pulled, at the schoolteacher's guard, and stopped, and the whole exchange had a quality Reilly recognised from halls in other countries, from judging panels and national squads and a level of the art he had visited as a younger man and chosen, deliberately, to leave: the quality of an exchange happening inside the count, as if time in its vicinity were being administered by the quieter of the two people.
"Again," he said, and watched it again. "Again."
The schoolteacher, flattered and exhausted, did her best three times. Ren adjusted to her each time, taking the technique as it came, never early, never late, and once, when the schoolteacher overbalanced on the step and came in too far and too fast for the drill, Ren's block simply was not where the schoolteacher expected a block to be, and neither was Ren, and the schoolteacher finished her technique against empty air and recovered, laughing, against her partner's steadying hand, having learned the most useful lesson in karate without anybody naming it.
Then Reilly changed the drill, which he had not been planning to do, and the senior students on the bench knew he had not been planning to do it, because the lesson plan was written on the whiteboard by the door in his square hand and this was not on it. It was a footwork exercise, plain to the point of insult: the whole class in lines, sliding forward, sliding back, sliding to each side on the count, no techniques, no partners, nothing but feet and floor and counting. Beginners groaned. It was the drill you give children to tire them out.