He reposted none of it. That was the part nobody at the dojo ever quite believed, afterward, when it became clear the page had simply gone quiet, because reposting the good material without the jokes would have been the sensible, public spirited thing, and several people told him so. His answer, when Mags put it to him directly, was the plainest thing he said that whole season.
"If I put the clean ones back up tonight," he said, "then tonight is about me fixing my page. It can be about the page some other month. This month it can be about why they came down." He shrugged, uncomfortable, a man still learning the weight of his own sentences. "Also she asked for no filming. Once. In writing. In front of everyone. It turns out that covers the old ones too. It always covered the old ones. I just had not read it that way."
The page stayed dark. The dojo, to the surprise of everyone who had believed the page was the dojo's lifeline to the town, did not suffer for it. Two new beginners arrived in the following fortnight, both by word of mouth, both saying the same thing in different words at the door: that they had heard it was a serious place, where an older person could start at the beginning and be left in peace to do it. Reilly, entering their names in the register in his narrow hand, said nothing about where such a rumour might have started. But that evening, in the office, he moved the register to a new page, although the old one was not full, and wrote the two names at the top with more space around them than his economy usually allowed, the way a man makes room on a wall for photographs he has not seen yet.
The roof decided the anniversary, in the end, the way the roof decided most things at Greystone.
The seam above the equipment cupboard, which had announced itself during the October rain, turned out on inspection to be the honest herald of a general surrender. The hall's roof was forty winters old and had kept out four decades of harbour weather with dignity, and the roofer, a former student who gave the dojo his family rate and his unfiltered opinion, stood in the yard with Reilly and Mags and said that dignity was not a material and the whole north slope wanted doing before spring.
The figure he named was large enough to silence all three of them. The dojo's accounts, kept by Reilly in pencil with a frugality that bordered on the devotional, could cover a third of it. The town grant might, in time, cover another third, if the forms were courted properly. The remaining third stood in the yard with them, unignorable, in the cold.
It was Mags who said it first, because Mags was the one rebuilding the photo wall and therefore the one thinking in anniversaries. "Then the anniversary earns it," she said. "A charity night. An exhibition. This town has watched its children grade in that hall for forty years, and half the harbour has a belt in a drawer somewhere. They will fill the hall for a roof. They filled it for less, the year of the fire."
Reilly said nothing, which everyone who knew him understood to be the sound of a man checking an idea for vanity, his own included. "An exhibition is a demonstration of what a dojo believes," he said at last. "Most are demonstrations of what a dojo can sell. If we do this, it will be the first kind, or it will not happen, and I will mend the roof with buckets and personal stubbornness, which are both in good supply." He looked up at the north slope. "Plan it. Both of you. Bring me a plan with the terms written down, because I have learned this autumn, at some cost to my pride, what happens in this hall when the terms are not written down."
So they planned it, in the office, over three evenings, with the register pushed aside and Mags's wall sketches under the mugs. The town's hall committee offered chairs. The boatyard offered to print the programme. The fisherman from the beginners' class, whose name was entered in the register with unusual space around it, offered the harbour choir, which sang at launches and funerals and would, he said, consider a roof a close relation of both.