“Yes.”
The word seemed to change the atmosphere in the room.
Emily pulled up the scanned page again. The personnel review contained a reference number, an opening date, and a final disposition. The case had supposedly been resolved through an internal administrative process, but the document did not identify the person who had authorized the final closure.
Now she knew that Anderson had ordered the file sealed.
“What happened to Marcus Hill?” she asked.
“He was arrested after the traffic stop. The arrest report stated that he had resisted officers and attempted to flee. During the arrest, he suffered a fractured jaw and several broken ribs.”
“Was force justified?”
“That was the question the investigation was supposed to answer.”
“And what did the investigation conclude?”
Anderson looked down at his hands.
“Officially, it concluded that the officers involved had acted within department policy.”
“Officially?”
He closed his eyes briefly.
“The evidence was inconsistent. One officer said Marcus had attacked him. Another said Marcus had been reaching into his vehicle. A third officer's statement contradicted both accounts. There was also a witness who claimed the officers had struck Marcus after he was already on the ground.”
“Was the witness interviewed?”
“Yes.”
“Was the interview preserved?”
“I believed it was.”
Emily waited.
Anderson drew a slow breath.
“Two days before the final report was issued, I received instructions to transfer the case to a special administrative review. Deputy Chief Voss was involved. He said the matter had attracted attention from senior officials and that we needed to ensure every procedural requirement had been met.”
“Who gave you those instructions?”
“I don't remember receiving them directly from anyone above Voss.”
“That isn't the same as not knowing.”
The captain looked up.
“You're right.”
Emily set the phone on the desk.
“Did you believe the investigation was compromised?”
“I had concerns.”
“What concerns?”
“The witness statement had changed. The original version described Marcus lying on the pavement when an officer struck him. The later version said the witness couldn't clearly see what happened.”
“Who changed it?”
“I never found out.”
“Did you investigate?”
Anderson's silence answered before he did.
“No.”
Emily leaned back slightly.
“Why not?”
“Because I was told the witness had voluntarily corrected the statement. I was also told that the original interview notes were incomplete and couldn't be relied upon.”
“Who told you that?”
“Voss.”
Emily wrote the name in her notebook.
“Captain, did you personally review the original statement?”
“I saw a copy.”
“Did you compare it with the revised version?”
“No. By the time I received the file, the review had already been completed.”
“Yet you ordered it sealed.”
Anderson flinched.
“I was told the file contained sensitive personnel information. I was instructed to restrict access until the department's legal office completed its review.”
“Did the legal office complete that review?”
“I believed it had.”
“Did you receive a written determination?”
“No.”
“Did you verify that the sealing order was legally authorized?”
Anderson stared at the desk.
“No.”
Emily allowed the silence to continue.
She was not interested in humiliating him. She needed to understand what he had done, what he had known, and whether his decisions had contributed to the concealment of evidence.
A person could make a serious mistake without being part of a conspiracy. But a serious mistake did not become harmless simply because the person making it had trusted the wrong colleague.
“Did you ever speak to Marcus Hill again?” she asked.
“No.”
“Did you know whether he had filed a civil lawsuit?”
“I heard that he had consulted an attorney.”
“Did you know whether he received compensation?”
“No.”
“Did you know whether the officers involved faced disciplinary action?”
“None that I was aware of.”
Emily closed her notebook.
“Then we need to establish what happened to that investigation.”
Anderson nodded slowly.
“I understand.”
“Do you? Because the current evidence suggests that complaints may have been altered, restricted, or closed without proper review. Your old case may be connected to the same administrative practices.”
He looked at her.
“You think this started four years ago?”
“I think we have evidence of questionable procedures dating back at least four years. Whether the cases are connected is something we must determine.”
Anderson rose and walked toward the window.
Outside, the parking lot was beginning to fill with afternoon vehicles. Officers crossed between buildings, carrying folders and speaking into radios. The department continued to function, but the captain could no longer look at the familiar scene without wondering how much of its history he had misunderstood.
“I never wanted to protect someone who had done something wrong,” he said.
Emily's voice remained measured.