Marcus said no.
Then Officer Daniel Price approached the driver's side and told him to step out.
Marcus asked why.
Price repeated the order.
Marcus complied.
He was instructed to stand beside the vehicle while the officers searched the interior. When he asked whether they had a warrant, Price told him to stop interfering.
“I didn't touch anyone,” Marcus said. “I didn't try to run. I didn't threaten them. I just wanted to know why they were searching my car.”
“What happened next?” Emily asked.
“Price told me to turn around. I asked whether I was under arrest. He grabbed my arm.”
Marcus paused.
His fingers tightened against the edge of the table.
“Then he shoved me against the car.”
Emily waited until he was ready to continue.
“The other officer came around the back. I remember saying that I wasn't resisting. Then Price hit me.”
“Did you see what he struck you with?”
“His fist. At least the first time. After that, I went down.”
“Were you conscious throughout the incident?”
“Not completely. I remember the pavement. I remember somebody pressing my shoulder into the ground. I remember trying to protect my head.”
He swallowed.
“When I woke up properly, I was in the ambulance.”
Emily recorded the details without interrupting.
“Did you recognize the second officer?”
“Not at the time. I learned his name later from the report.”
“Was it Officer Daniel Price and another patrol officer?”
“Yes.”
“Did you see any supervisor at the scene?”
“No.”
Marcus leaned forward.
“But there was something else. Something I didn't understand until later.”
Emily waited.
“Before the officers pulled me out of the car, Price was talking to someone on his radio. I couldn't hear the other person's words, but I heard Price say my name.”
“Your full name?”
“Yes.”
“Are you certain?”
“I'm certain he said Marcus Hill.”
Emily wrote it down.
“Did he explain why he knew your name before asking for your identification?”
“No. I assumed he'd read my license plate or run the registration.”
“Did you later discover that your name was associated with an investigation?”
Marcus nodded.
“My attorney found a reference to an investigative file in the documents the city provided. Nobody ever explained what it meant.”
“Do you have a copy?”
“My attorney does.”
Emily made a note to request the material through the appropriate channel.
“Mr. Hill, I need to ask you about the interview recording. Do you remember being questioned by Deputy Chief Voss?”
Marcus's face darkened.
“Yes.”
“What do you remember about that conversation?”
“He kept asking me whether I wanted to make things difficult for everyone.”
“Did he threaten you?”
“Not in a way that would sound like a direct threat if you wrote it in a report.”
“Can you explain?”
Marcus looked toward his attorney, then back at Emily.
“He said the department was dealing with a complicated situation. He said several people could lose their jobs if I continued pursuing the complaint. Then he asked whether I really wanted to be responsible for that.”
Emily remained still.
“What did you tell him?”
“I told him I wasn't responsible for what his officers had done.”
Marcus's voice became quieter.
“Then he said I should think carefully about the consequences of accusing people with families.”
Emily looked down at her notes.
“Did he mention your family?”
“No. But he didn't need to. He knew where I worked. He knew where I lived. And he knew my mother's name.”
Emily paused.
“Had anyone contacted your mother?”
“Not that I could prove.”
“Did she ever tell you that someone had approached her?”
Marcus hesitated.
Then he nodded.
“About two weeks after the complaint was closed, a man came to her house. He said he was from the city and wanted to discuss a routine administrative matter.”
“Did he identify himself?”
“He showed her a badge. She couldn't remember the name afterward.”
“What did he want?”
“He asked whether I was still planning to pursue the case. He said that the city wanted to resolve the matter privately and that it would be better for everyone if we stopped talking about it.”
Emily felt the significance of the statement immediately.
“Did your mother report the visit?”
“No. She was frightened. She told me about it after the settlement.”
“Why didn't you mention it in your original complaint?”
“Because I didn't know it had happened until afterward.”
Emily wrote down the information and asked Marcus to describe the visitor as accurately as possible.
He remembered a dark suit, a silver watch, and a small scar near the man's left ear.