“Not on the box. The media itself may have metadata, depending on the format.”
Patricia documented the container and removed a small optical disc from its protective sleeve.
The handwritten label on the disc matched the case number.
But there was another mark beneath it.
A second case number had been crossed out.
Emily leaned closer.
“Can you read that?”
Patricia adjusted the light.
“Possibly. It looks like the final digits are three-one-seven.”
Emily checked her notes.
Rebecca Miller's complaint number ended in three-one-seven.
The connection might be accidental. Numbering systems sometimes repeated digits, especially across different categories of cases. But the disc's label suggested that someone had reused or altered the original container.
They would need to verify the record before drawing any conclusions.
“Let's make a forensic copy,” Emily said. “Preserve the original and document the transfer process. No one should play it on an ordinary workstation if we can avoid that.”
Patricia contacted the digital evidence specialist.
By early afternoon, the disc had been imaged through an approved process, and the resulting copy was verified. The original was returned to secure storage under a new documented seal.
Emily and Patricia then moved to a designated review room.
The digital evidence specialist loaded the verified copy.
The screen displayed a timestamp from four years earlier.
The recording began.
A younger Marcus Hill sat in a small interview room, his face swollen, one eye bruised, and a bandage wrapped around his jaw. He wore a hospital shirt beneath a borrowed jacket.
Across the table sat an interviewer whose face was partially visible.
A second person stood near the door.
Emily recognized the voice immediately.
Robert Voss.
“Mr. Hill,” the recording began, “we need to establish exactly what happened during your encounter with our officers.”
Marcus shifted in his chair.
“I already told the other detective.”
“We're reviewing the matter again.”
“Why?”
“Because there are inconsistencies in the statements.”
Marcus gave a bitter laugh that ended in a grimace.
“The only inconsistency is that your officers keep changing their stories.”
The interviewer glanced toward Voss.
Voss stepped forward.
“Mr. Hill, I understand that you're upset. But if you want anyone to take your complaint seriously, you need to remain calm and answer the questions.”
Marcus stared at him.
“I was calm when they pulled me over. I was calm when they told me to get out. I was calm when I asked why they were searching my car. Then one of them grabbed me, another pushed me down, and somebody started hitting me.”
“Which officer struck you?”
“Price.”
Emily froze.
Daniel Price had been involved four years earlier.
Marcus continued.
“Price hit me first. The other one joined in. I couldn't see who it was after they turned me over.”
“Did you resist arrest?”
“No.”
“Did you attempt to reach into your vehicle?”
“No.”
“Did you threaten any of the officers?”
“No.”
Voss leaned against the table.
“Mr. Hill, we have statements indicating that you became aggressive.”
“Then show me the statements.”
“We're not here to debate evidence.”
“Then why am I here?”
The question silenced the room.
Marcus looked directly at the camera.
“Because you already decided what happened before you asked me.”
Emily watched without blinking.
The interviewer shuffled papers.
“Mr. Hill, if the department determines that the officers acted within policy, are you willing to accept that finding?”
“No.”
“Would you consider withdrawing your complaint if the department offered you an opportunity to resolve the matter privately?”
Marcus stared at him.
“Are you asking me to say they didn't hurt me?”
“No one is asking you to say anything untrue.”
“Then stop asking me to withdraw a complaint about something that happened.”
The recording continued for another twenty minutes. Marcus described the traffic stop, the physical confrontation, the ambulance ride, and the hospital examination. He identified the location of the incident and named two people who had witnessed the aftermath.
Then Voss asked a question that made Emily sit forward.
“Mr. Hill, did you know that Officer Price was working under special instructions that evening?”
Marcus frowned.
“No.”
“Did you know that your vehicle had been flagged for investigation?”
“No. Why would it be?”
The interviewer glanced down at a document.
Voss's tone changed.
“Your name appeared in a report connected to an ongoing investigation. The officers were instructed to approach your vehicle and verify certain information.”
“What investigation?”
“I can't discuss the details.”
“Then how was I supposed to know I was part of it?”
Voss did not answer.
Marcus leaned forward.
“You keep talking about instructions. Who gave them? What was I supposed to have done?”
The interviewer intervened.
“Mr. Hill, let's return to the incident itself.”