“And find out who requested the replacement backup device.”
“That might take time.”
“Then start now.”
She ended the call and returned to the maintenance logs.
The third work order contained a short technical note:
Previous backup medium removed for security inspection. Replacement installed. Legacy index not restored.
No explanation identified who had ordered the removal. No inventory number was recorded for the original device. There was no evidence that the missing medium had ever been returned.
Emily printed the page.
If the original backup contained Ethan's complaint, the records associated with Marcus Hill, or communications between Price and Voss, then the missing device might explain why so many documents had vanished.
But she needed proof. A missing backup was suspicious, not conclusive. She would not allow the investigation to become a collection of coincidences held together by fear.
She began building a timeline.
Ethan reported unauthorized access involving Daniel Price.
Two days later, Marcus Hill was stopped and injured during a traffic encounter involving Price.
The internal review concerning Ethan was closed by Voss.
Ethan's account was disabled.
The records server experienced a series of maintenance events.
Michael Reed appeared in the maintenance record.
Weeks later, Ethan's employment was recorded as a voluntary resignation, despite the absence of the documents normally required to support one.
And years afterward, Marcus's complaint and Rebecca Miller's complaint were found to have been handled through suspiciously similar procedures.
Emily drew a line beneath the sequence.
Someone might eventually offer an innocent explanation for one event. Explaining all of them would be much harder.
At 9:32, her phone rang again.
A woman spoke in a low voice.
“Ms. Carter?”
“Yes. Who is this?”
“My name doesn't matter right now.”
“It matters if you're asking me to rely on information that could affect an investigation.”
There was a pause.
“I used to work in the department's technology office. I was there when the backup device was removed.”
Emily sat forward.
“Were you the person who left the message?”
“Yes.”
“Can you tell me what happened?”
“I can tell you what I saw. I can't tell you what was on the device because I was never allowed to examine it.”
“Who removed it?”
“Michael Reed carried it out. Martin Hale signed the release form. Deputy Chief Voss stood in the doorway while it happened.”
Emily wrote down the names, although none surprised her.
“Was there a security inspection?”
“That's what the work order said. But no one from security came to the room. Reed arrived with a case, disconnected the device, placed it inside, and left. The replacement was installed before the afternoon shift.”
“Did anyone question the removal?”
“I did.”
“What happened?”
“My supervisor told me the order came from the deputy chief and that I should stop asking questions.”
“Did you see the original work order?”
“Yes. It had a reference number, but the number was crossed out on the copy I saw. Someone wrote a different number beside it.”
“Do you still have a copy?”
Another pause.
“I kept something.”
Emily lowered her voice. “What did you keep?”
“A photograph of the work order. And a photograph of the sign-out sheet. I took them because the whole thing felt wrong.”
“Why didn't you report it?”
“Because I had a mortgage, two children, and a supervisor who told me I could lose my job if I repeated what I had seen. Then Ethan disappeared. I convinced myself that staying quiet was the safest choice.”
Emily did not criticize her. She had heard versions of that explanation from witnesses before. Fear did not always make people brave. Sometimes it made them wait until they believed the danger had passed.
“Are you willing to provide those photographs to our investigators?”
“I might be.”
“What would help you decide?”
“I need to know that Deputy Chief Voss can't find out who I am before you can protect me.”
Emily looked at the closed office door.
“I can't promise that nobody will ever learn your identity. If your evidence becomes part of a formal proceeding, disclosure rules may apply. But I can arrange a confidential meeting, document your concerns, and explain the protections available before you provide anything. You will not have to walk into the police station to do it.”
The woman breathed shakily into the phone.
“Can we meet somewhere else?”
“Yes. Tell me where and when you feel safe enough to talk, and we'll arrange it through our office.”
“I'll call you back.”
“Please do. And don't attempt to retrieve anything from a place where you think someone may be watching you.”
The line went silent.