At school the following week, Lily's teacher, Mrs. Alvarez, noticed a change in her that was small enough to miss if you were not looking, but clear enough to matter if you were. Lily had always been a quiet child in class, not shy exactly, but careful, the kind of girl who listened first and spoke second, who liked to finish her work neatly before she showed it to anyone. Now she was quieter still, and she watched the door more often, and when the classroom grew loud she put her hands over her ears for a second before she remembered to take them down again. She still did her work, and her reading was still strong, and she still helped the younger children in the reading corner without being asked, but Mrs. Alvarez could see that something was weighing on her, the way a child carries a heavy bag and tries not to let anyone see how heavy it is.
One morning, during free drawing time, Lily drew the same table and the same cup again, without anyone asking her to, and Mrs. Alvarez, who had been walking between the desks, paused behind her chair. She did not take the drawing away or ask Lily to explain it in front of the other children. She knelt down and said, that is a very careful drawing, Lily, and Lily nodded and kept colouring the cup brown. Mrs. Alvarez noticed the small bottle beside it, coloured red at the lid, and she noticed the figure slumped over the table, and she noticed the small girl standing beside him, and she felt a cold feeling in her stomach that she did not yet have words for. She said, would you like to put this one in your folder to take home, and Lily said yes, and Mrs. Alvarez helped her slide it into the clear plastic folder she kept in her desk, and Lily went back to her maths worksheet as if nothing had happened.
At lunchtime, Mrs. Alvarez called Ethan, not to alarm him, but because she had known Lily since September and she thought he should know what she had seen. She chose her words carefully, and she did not guess at what the drawing meant, and she did not ask Ethan to explain anything he was not ready to explain. She said Lily seemed tired, and a little watchful, and that she had drawn a picture of her father asleep at a table with a cup and a small bottle beside it, and that Lily had put it in her folder to take home. Ethan thanked her, and told her, in brief and simple terms, that there were things happening at home, that Lily was seeing a kind person called Dr. Grant who was helping her talk about them, and that he would like school to stay as normal as possible for her. Mrs. Alvarez said of course, and that she would keep an eye on Lily, and that if Lily wanted to draw, she could draw, and if she wanted to play, she could play, and that nobody at school would ask her difficult questions.
In the third session with Dr. Grant, Lily was more relaxed, and she went straight to the table and started drawing without lining up the crayons first, which Dr. Grant later told Ethan was a good sign, a sign that she felt safe enough not to need the ritual. She drew her father at the table again, but this time she drew the papers too, white rectangles spread out in front of him, with wavy lines on them that were meant to be writing, and a big shape at the bottom of one of them that was meant to be a signature. She pointed to the signature and said, Daddy's name, but it looks funny, and Dr. Grant asked what she meant by funny, and Lily said, it goes wobbly, like when I write with my left hand. Ethan, sitting by the wall, felt his breath catch, because he had not told Lily anything about the signatures, and she had noticed, on her own, that his hand had not moved the way it usually moved. She had watched him sign his name while he was drowsy, and she had seen the wobble, and she had remembered it.
Dr. Grant asked, gently, if Lily remembered anything else about the papers, and Lily said, Mummy says sign here, and points, and Daddy signs, and then Mummy takes the papers away quick. She drew a hand taking the papers away, a big hand scooping them up off the table, and she coloured the papers white and the hand pink, and she said, she puts them in a bag, a black bag. Ethan thought about Nora's black leather bag, the one she carried to