Nora came downstairs later, dressed as if she were going out, her hair brushed and her makeup done, and she sat at the far end of the kitchen table and asked Ethan if they could talk. Ethan said no. He said they would talk later, when Lily was not in the room, and he said it in a voice that left no space for argument. Nora looked at Lily, and Lily looked down at her plate, and Nora stood up and went into the living room, and Ethan heard her on the phone, her voice low, talking to someone about the house and about money, and he thought about the way she had always talked about the house.
The house was large and beautiful, with marble floors and tall windows and a garden that Mrs. Ortiz tended with care, and Ethan had bought it when Carter Holdings was still small, when he was still building the company one property at a time. It had been a dream then, a place where his family could live well, where Lily could grow up with space to run and draw and play. Nora had loved the house from the first day she saw it. She loved the kitchen with its wide counters and the dining room with its long table and the living room where the light came in through the tall windows in the afternoon. She loved the way people looked at her when she told them where she lived. She loved the life that came with the house, the clothes and the car and the holidays and the invitations, and Ethan had always known that she loved those things, but he had never thought that love could turn into fear, or that fear could turn into something that would make her put a substance in his tea.
In the months before that afternoon, Nora had talked about money more than she used to. She had talked about the house as if it might be taken away, about the company as if it might fail, about the transfers Ethan needed to sign to keep everything safe. She had brought him papers in the evenings, after dinner, when he was tired, and she had said, "Just sign here, Ethan. It is only a transfer. It will keep the house in the family. It will keep everything the way it is." Ethan had signed some of them. He had not signed others. He had told her he wanted to read them properly, that he wanted his lawyer to look at them, and Nora had smiled and said of course, and then she had brought him tea, and the next day she had brought the papers again, and sometimes she had told him he had already signed them, that he must have forgotten, that he had been tired.
Ethan had believed her then. He had believed her because she was his wife, because he had no reason not to believe her, because he was tired and busy and his head hurt and he could not remember clearly what he had read the day before. He had believed her because it was easier to believe her than to admit that something was wrong, and because he loved Lily and he wanted their family to be whole, and because the alternative was too frightening to think about.
Lily's drawings were spread out on the rug in the living room that morning, where she had left them the day before. Ethan sat down on the floor beside her while she drew, and he looked at the pictures she had made. There was a house with a red door and a garden with flowers. There was a dog with long ears and a sun with a smiling face. There was a picture of Ethan, tall and smiling, holding Lily's hand, and a picture of Mrs. Ortiz with an apron, and a picture of the kitchen with a kettle on the stove. There was no picture of Nora in the pile that morning, and Ethan noticed it, and he did not say anything about it, but he kept it in his mind.
Lily drew the way she always drew, carefully and slowly, her tongue caught between her teeth, her crayons lined up in a neat row beside her paper. She liked to draw her family, and she liked to draw the house, and she liked to draw the garden, and she told Ethan stories about each picture as she made it, stories about the dog and the sun and the house with the red door. That morning she drew a new picture, a picture of a cup on a table, and she coloured the cup white and the tea inside it dark, and she drew a small girl beside the table with her arms outstretched, and she did not say anything about the picture, but Ethan knew what it was, and he put his hand on her shoulder and said, "That is a very good drawing, sweetheart," and Lily nodded and kept drawing.