had been found, on a shelf in the kitchen, beside the tea jars, and she watched his eyes move across the image and settle on the label. She asked him to think carefully, because the record would show what he said now, and she asked him whether he had ever bought anything like it, or ordered anything like it, or given anything like it to his sister. He said no, and then he said that he wanted water, and Bennett paused the recording and brought him a cup and waited while he drank it, and when she started the recording again she asked the same question in different words, about messages between him and Nora in the weeks before the transfers, and about calls made late at night, when Ethan would have been asleep.
The phone records were the part Adrian had not prepared for. Bennett laid out a simple list, dates and times and numbers, without commentary, and she read them aloud one by one, and with each one she asked him to explain what the call had been about. At first he gave short answers, a question about a plumber, a question about their mother, a question about a school event for Lily, but the list kept going, and the calls grew longer and later, and some of them lasted forty minutes, and some of them were made at one in the morning, and Bennett did not raise her voice when the answers stopped fitting. She asked about a message Nora had sent him on a Tuesday evening, a short message that said only that Ethan had signed and that it had worked, and she asked what had worked, and what Ethan had signed, and why Nora would need to tell her brother that at half past eleven at night. Adrian stared at the table and said that he did not remember that message, and Bennett said that she understood that memory could be uncertain, and she showed him the message itself, printed out, with his reply underneath it, a reply that said good, keep going, and she asked him to read his own words aloud for the recording.
He read them, very quietly, and then he stopped, and for a full minute the room was silent except for the hum of the recording machine. Bennett waited. She had learned that the silence after a person's own words were read back to them did more work than any question, and she did not fill it. Adrian put his hands flat on the table, as if to steady himself, and he looked up and said that he wanted to tell the truth now, that he had been lying, that he was sorry, and Bennett said that she was listening and that he should take his time and start at the beginning. He began with Nora, and with the way she had talked to him for months about the house, about the money, about the fear that Ethan would leave and take the life she had built with him, and about the way she had said, again and again, that she did not want to lose everything. He said that he had listened because he was her brother and because he had always been the person she called when she was frightened, and that over time listening had turned into helping, and helping had turned into planning, and he had not noticed the moment when it changed.
He admitted that he had supplied the little bottle. He said that he had obtained it through a contact he would name, a man who sold things without asking questions, and that he had given it to Nora in a car park, wrapped in a paper bag, and that he had told her it would only make Ethan sleep, that it was a sedative, that it would make him drowsy and easy to manage, and that he had believed that because he had wanted to believe it. He said that he had never asked what was in it, not properly, and that he had never thought about what it might do to a man who drank it again and again, night after night, for six months. He said that Nora had told him Ethan was signing papers while he was drowsy, and that the papers moved money and property toward Northgate Holdings Ltd, an account Adrian had helped to set up because Nora had said it was for a new investment, a safe place to hold money while Ethan was ill, and that he had believed her, or had told himself that he believed her, because the money was going to his sister and not to a stranger.