Zara was standing on the third riser at the back, between two girls from the sixth grade, trying to make herself as small as the riser would allow. The white blouse Denise had bought her felt stiff against her neck. The tags were gone now. Her mother had cut them off that morning in the kitchen, with the small scissors from the junk drawer, and had folded them and put them in her purse, as if keeping them might somehow keep the choice open. Zara had watched her mother's hands. They had been steady. Zara's own hands were not steady. She kept them folded in front of her, the way Ms. Johnson had taught the choir to stand, and she tried to listen to the music and not to the size of the room.
The Orpheum was larger than any room she had ever stood in. The ceiling seemed impossibly high. The seats stretched back in rows that disappeared into a soft darkness, and beyond the darkness there were cameras, and beyond the cameras there were two million people she could not see. She thought about Jayden and Malik, at home with Rosa's neighbour for the evening, and she wished, suddenly and fiercely, that she were at home making mac and cheese and listening to Malik ask for one more song. She thought about her mother in the audience, and her grandmother in her best coat, and she told herself that if she kept her eyes on the back of the girl in front of her, the evening would pass, and the choir would sing, and nobody would notice her at all.
Chase was talking about the school. He talked about Jefferson Elementary as if he had walked its halls that morning, as if he knew the names of its children. He talked about underprivileged schools, and about opportunity, and about how music had saved him, and the audience murmured its approval. A photograph of the choir appeared on the large screen behind him, taken during rehearsal that afternoon. Zara saw herself in the back row, half hidden, and she felt a small, unexpected flush of pride. Then Chase stopped talking. He looked past the front rows. He looked past the middle rows. He looked, deliberately, all the way to the back.
You there, he said.
His voice sliced through the theater. It was not the warm, practised voice he had used for the introduction. It was sharper, flatter, and it carried. Five hundred heads turned. The cameras turned with them.
The girl in the back with the cheap uniform. Come up here now.
Zara felt the words land like a hand on her chest. Cheap uniform. She looked down at her white blouse. It was new. Her mother had bought it at the discount store, and it had cost money they did not have to spare, and Denise had ironed it twice. It was not a uniform. The other choir children were wearing the school's dark blue polo shirts. Zara was wearing the white blouse because her mother had wanted her to look her best, and because the blue shirts had run out in her size. She had not thought about it all evening. Now she could think about nothing else.
She did not move. She could not move. Her feet felt as if they had been glued to the riser. The girl beside her shifted away, just a little, as if distance might protect her. Mr. Alvarez, standing at the side of the risers with his hands clasped, looked up at Chase with his mouth slightly open, as if he were trying to decide whether he had heard correctly.
Come up here now, Chase said again, and this time there was a smile in his voice, the kind of smile that is not a smile at all. "Don't be shy. We are all friends here."
Zara's hands trembled. She looked toward the wings, where the stage manager was standing with a clipboard pressed to her chest. The stage manager looked back at her, and then at Chase, and then down at her clipboard, as if the clipboard might contain an instruction for this moment. It did not. Nobody had rehearsed this.
I'm sorry, sir, Zara said, and her voice came out small and thin, barely reaching the microphone clipped to the front of the riser. "I didn't mean—"
Save it.
He was already walking toward her. He came down the steps at the side of the stage and up the aisle between the risers, and the choir children parted for him without being asked. He smelled of cologne and hair product and something sharper underneath, like peppermint. He reached her, and his hand closed around her upper arm, just above the elbow, and then moved to her shoulder, and he turned her toward the front of the stage. His grip was not hard enough to hurt, but it was hard enough to control. It was hard enough that she understood, without him saying so, that she was not being invited.
Let's see if you can actually sing, he said, loudly enough for the microphones to catch it, loudly enough for the audience to laugh, a little, uncertainly, "or if you're just taking up space."