Famous Singer Forced Black Girl to Sing Solo to Mock Her — However, She Hit Notes He Never Could

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She had been proud of the choir. She was still proud of the choir. What she was not proud of was the feeling, settling slowly in her chest, that the school had been used as a backdrop. The children had sung well. They had stood in the back row in their uniforms and done everything Mr. Alvarez had asked of them. And then a famous man had taken one of them into the spotlight and tried to make her small, in front of five hundred people and two million viewers, and Karen Ellis did not intend to let the evening end with a photograph and a thank-you.

Mr. Alvarez arrived before the first bell, carrying his satchel and a folder that was thicker than usual. He set the folder on Karen's desk without a word. Inside were the emails about the gala, the permission slips, the bus schedule, and the single sheet of paper that had come with the invitation, the one that had said the funds raised would benefit the school's music program. There was no number on it. There was no date. There was no signature that meant anything at all.

We should have asked, Mr. Alvarez said.

We asked what we knew to ask, Karen said. "Now we know more."

She called Denise Williams before the children arrived. Denise was awake, though she had worked the night before, and her voice was steady in the way it always was when she was protecting Zara. Karen told her what she intended to do. She intended to write to the gala's organisers and ask, in writing, for a full accounting of the money raised that night: how much had come in, where it had gone, and what portion, if any, had reached Jefferson Elementary or any other school named in the program. She intended to ask for an independent audit, conducted by someone who had not organised the gala, and she intended to make the request public, so that it could not be answered with a private reassurance.

Denise listened without interrupting. Then she said, "Do not use Zara's name to raise another dollar. Not without my written consent. Not for the gala, not for the school, not for anyone."

I would not, Karen said. "And I will put that in the letter."

Angela Brooks arrived at the school an hour later, with a notebook and a calm that filled the small office like fresh air. She read Karen's draft letter twice, changed three sentences so that they were shorter and harder to misunderstand, and added one of her own: the audit would be independent, and its findings would be shared with the schools named in the program. She told Karen that an audit was not an accusation. It was a record. And a record was what children deserved when adults had raised money in their names.

The photographs matter too, Angela said. "The children were photographed with a man who was posing with them. Those photographs were used to sell tickets. If any of them are used again, the families decide, not the gala."

Karen nodded. She thought of the choir risers, of the way the children had stood together, of Zara in her new white blouse, and of the way the evening had been described in the press as generous. Generosity, she thought, should be able to survive being counted.

That afternoon, the gala's organisers replied with a statement, not a number. It thanked the school, praised the choir, and said that the fundraising total would be announced in due course. Karen read it aloud to Mr. Alvarez, and then she read it again, more slowly, and neither of them could find a figure in it anywhere.

Due course, Mr. Alvarez repeated.

Due course is not a date, Karen said.

She wrote back the same day. She asked again, politely and in writing, for the total, the disbursements, and the audit. She copied Angela Brooks. She copied the school district. She did not copy the press, because she did not need to; the press was already asking the same questions, and the questions were now being asked in public, by people who had watched the gala and who remembered the photographs.

In the days that followed, the numbers began to arrive in pieces, the way news arrives when nobody wants to give it all at once. A ticketing figure appeared in a trade publication. A sponsorship figure appeared in another. A former volunteer, speaking without giving her name, said that the gala had raised more money than any of Chase Hendricks's previous galas, and that the children in the photographs had been told the money was for their schools. Angela Brooks collected each figure the way a nurse collects a chart, quietly and without comment, and put them in a file.

Denise, meanwhile, kept her own record. She kept the program, the permission slip, and the photograph of Zara on the risers that Rosa had taken from the audience. She kept them in the drawer with the bills, because that was where the important papers lived. When a reporter called and asked whether Zara would appear at a follow-up fundraiser, Denise said no, and she said it the same way she said everything important: once, clearly, and without raising her voice.

The audit is not about punishing anyone, Karen told the choir parents at a short meeting after school, with Mr. Alvarez beside her and Angela Brooks standing at the back of the room. "It is about making sure that when we tell children their singing raised money for their school, that is true."

News in the same category

Famous Singer Forced Black Girl to Sing Solo to Mock Her — However, She Hit Notes He Never Could

45 Part