Victor's office was at the end of the corridor. It was a large room, with a heavy desk and tall windows and shelves full of scores and books, and a portrait of Victor himself on the wall behind the desk, painted when he was younger and his hair was darker. Nora had been in this room before, to clean it, early in the morning, before Victor arrived. She had dusted the desk and emptied the bin and straightened the chairs, and she had never sat in any of them.
She remembered, suddenly and clearly, Elias telling her about this room. He had come home that last night, the night he had been dismissed, and he had sat at their kitchen table and described it to her, not because he wanted her to picture it, but because he could not stop picturing it himself. The desk. The windows. The way Victor had sat behind the desk and told him the partnership was over, and the scores belonged to the house, and he should leave them and go. The way Elias had stood in front of that desk, a composer with nothing in his hands, and had understood, in that moment, that the man he had trusted had been planning this for a long time.
Now Nora stood in that same room, and Chloe stood beside her, and Daniel stood beside Chloe, and the board members came in behind them, and Victor went around to the far side of the desk and sat down in his chair, as if sitting there would make him safe, as if the desk itself would protect him.
His lawyer stood beside him. Marcus came in last, carrying a folder, and he set it on the desk without opening it, and then he stood near the door, a little apart from everyone else, his hands empty now.
"Close the door, Marcus," Victor said.
Marcus closed the door.
For a moment, no one spoke. The room was quiet except for the sound of the rain that had begun outside, tapping lightly against the tall windows. Nora could hear her own breathing. She could feel Chloe's hand in hers.
Then the woman in the dark blue dress, whose name Nora learned later was Mrs. Alden, cleared her throat. "Mr. Blackwood," she said, "Mr. Hart has brought papers that he says prove the symphony performed tonight was written by Elias Cole, not by you. He has also brought, he says, a recording. Before this goes any further, before anyone makes any public statement, the board would like to see those papers, and to hear that recording, and to hear your response, here, in private, where we can consider them properly."
Victor nodded, as if this were reasonable, as if he had suggested it himself. "Of course," he said. "I have nothing to hide. Mr. Hart, show us your papers."
Daniel set his box on the desk. It was an old box, cardboard, its corners soft with age, and he opened it carefully, as if it contained something fragile, which in a way it did. He took out the manuscripts first, one by one, and laid them on the desk in a neat row. They were Elias's originals, in his handwriting, the notes slanting a little to the right, the way his hand had always slanted when he wrote fast. The dates were written in the top corner of each page, in the same hand, in ink that had faded a little with time but was still clear.
"This one," Daniel said, touching the first page gently, "is dated the winter before the partnership ended. This one is dated the spring. This one is dated the summer, three months before Elias was dismissed from this room. The melody that Chloe played tonight is here, on this page, in this hand, on this date. It is also here, in the second movement, and here, in the final movement. It is not a coincidence. It is the same music, written down by the same man, months before Mr. Blackwood says he wrote it."
The older man with white hair, Mr. Whitfield, leaned forward and picked up one of the pages. He held it carefully, by the edges, and he looked at it for a long time. He was a musician himself, Nora had heard, a retired conductor, and he knew what a composer's handwriting looked like, and what a date looked like, and what a melody looked like when it had been written by someone who had heard it in his head first.
"This is Elias's hand," he said quietly. "I knew Elias. I saw his scores when he was young. This is his hand. There is no doubt about that."
Victor's lawyer leaned forward. "With respect, Mr. Whitfield, handwriting can be imitated. Dates can be written later. A page with a date on it is not proof that the music on that page was written on that date, or that it was not written by someone else first."