He Bet $100 Million That a Penniless Little Girl Couldn't Play His Unpublished Symphony — Then She Played Every Note by Heart

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Nora sat beside her while they listened, and she did not cry, not then, although her eyes were bright. She put her arm around Chloe and said, "That is him. That is exactly him," and Chloe believed her, because she could hear it too, even though she had never heard him before, the way he paused before the important part, the way he said her name as if it were the beginning of a song.

The letters came next, in a bundle tied with a piece of string that had faded from red to pink. Daniel had kept them in a drawer, in envelopes that Elias had addressed in his own hand, and he had not opened them, because they were not his to open. He gave them to Nora in their kitchen, and Nora's hands shook when she took them, and then she laughed a little at herself, and said, "I am being silly. They are only letters."

"They are not only letters," Daniel said. "They are his."

Nora read the first one aloud, slowly, because her eyes kept blurring and she had to stop and wipe them and start again. It was written to Chloe, for when she was older, and it began the way all his letters began, with her name, and it said that he hoped she liked music, and that if she did, she should never let anyone tell her that it belonged to them and not to her. It said that he had written a piece for her, a long piece, a whole symphony, and that it was hers, and that one day she would play it and people would know his name again, and hers with it. It said that he was sorry he would not be there to hear it, and that he loved her, and that he would be listening anyway, in whatever way fathers who are gone get to listen.

Chloe sat very still while her mother read, her hands folded in her lap, and when Nora finished, Chloe said, "Read it again." So Nora read it again, and this time Chloe closed her eyes and listened to the words as if they were music, too.

There were other letters, one for each birthday Elias had known he would miss, and one for Nora, and one for Daniel, thanking him for being the kind of friend who kept things safe. There were notebooks, too, small ones with soft covers, full of Elias's ideas, half-finished tunes, notes in the margins about what to cook for dinner and what to buy for the baby, and on the last page of one notebook, in his clearest handwriting, a single sentence: "The music is for Chloe. It was always for Chloe."

Nora pressed that notebook to her chest for a moment, and then she put it down gently on the table, as if it might break, and she said, "We will keep these safe. We will keep them where Chloe can read them whenever she wants. They are not going back into a box in someone else's office."

Daniel nodded. "No. They are staying with you. That is where they belong."

In the weeks that followed, the truth moved outward in widening circles, the way a stone moves water when it is dropped in. The board, having received the examiners' reports, made a public statement that Elias Cole was the composer of the symphony, and that the work had been wrongly attributed. The statement was short, and careful, and it did not use grand words. It said what had been found, and who had found it, and what would happen next. Newspapers printed it. People who had known Elias wrote to Nora, some of them people she had not heard from in years, saying they had always wondered, saying they were glad, saying they remembered him playing in a small room with the window open, saying they had never believed Victor's version of the story.

Chloe did not read the newspapers. Nora read them first, and then she told Chloe the parts that mattered, in her own words, at the kitchen table, over dinner, the way she told her everything that mattered. "People know now," she said. "Your father's name is on the music again. That is the part that matters."

News in the same category

He Bet $100 Million That a Penniless Little Girl Couldn't Play His Unpublished Symphony — Then She Played Every Note by Heart

45 Part