He Bet $100 Million That a Penniless Little Girl Couldn't Play His Unpublished Symphony — Then She Played Every Note by Heart

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Then look at the letters," Daniel said, and he took out a small bundle of letters, tied with a piece of string, and laid them on the desk beside the manuscripts. "These are letters Elias wrote to me, over two years. In them, he talks about the symphony. He talks about the first movement, and the second, and the third. He talks about the problems he was having with the ending, and the way he solved them. He talks about playing parts of it for Chloe when she was a baby, and about hoping, one day, that she would play it herself. The letters are dated. The postmarks are on the envelopes. You can check them."

Mrs. Alden picked up one of the letters and read it, slowly, and then she passed it to Mr. Whitfield, who read it too. Neither of them said anything for a moment.

"And the recording," Daniel said. He took out a small, old recorder, the kind that used tapes, and he set it on the desk. "This is a home recording. Elias made it in his own kitchen, on a piano that was out of tune, because that was the piano we had. He recorded the main theme, and he talked while he played, about what he was trying to do. You can hear his voice. You can hear Chloe, as a baby, crying in the background, and Nora telling her to hush, and Elias laughing. It is dated, on the tape, in his voice. He says the date at the beginning. You can hear it."

He pressed play.

The sound that came out of the small recorder was thin and crackling, and at first it was hard to hear, but then a piano began to play, a little out of tune, a little hesitant, and then a man's voice, warm and familiar, said the date, and then he began to play the theme, the same theme Chloe had played that night, only slower, only simpler, only the beginning of what it would become.

Nora closed her eyes. She had not heard that recording in years. She had not heard Elias's voice in years, not like that, not speaking and playing at the same time, not in their kitchen, with Chloe crying in the background and her own voice, younger, telling the baby to hush. She felt Chloe's hand tighten in hers, and she opened her eyes and looked down, and Chloe was listening, her face very still, her eyes fixed on the small recorder as if it were the most important thing in the room.

Victor sat behind his desk, and he listened too, and his face did not change, but his hand, the hand with the big gold ring, tightened around the arm of his chair.

When the recording ended, Daniel pressed stop, and the room was quiet again, except for the rain.

"That is my husband," Nora said, and her voice was steady, even though her heart was beating very fast. "That is his voice. That is his piano. That is our kitchen. That is my daughter, as a baby. That is the music he wrote. It was his before it was ever played in this hall, and it was his when he was dismissed from this room, and it is still his now."

Mrs. Alden looked at him. "Mr. Blackwood," she said, "are you saying that Elias Cole contributed to the symphony?"

Victor hesitated. It was a small hesitation, but everyone in the room saw it, because it was the first time he had admitted anything at all.

"I am saying that we worked together," he said carefully. "I am saying that ideas were shared. I am saying that the partnership was a real partnership, and that the work that came out of it belonged to the partnership, and that when the partnership ended, the work remained with the house."

"And the manuscripts?" Mr. Whitfield asked. He was still holding one of Elias's pages, carefully, by the edges. "These are not shared ideas. These are complete movements, in Elias's hand, dated before the partnership ended. How do you explain them?"

"I explain them," Victor said, "by saying that Elias was a talented man who wrote down many things, and that not everything he wrote down became the symphony, and that the symphony, as performed, is a different thing from a set of pages in a box."

Daniel shook his head. "Victor," he said, and he used Victor's first name for the first time that night, "you know that is not true. You were there when Elias played the first movement for you, in this room, at that piano in the corner. You told him it was the best thing he had ever written. You told him it would make both your names. And then, when it was finished, you told him to leave it behind, because it belonged to the house. You know what you did. You have known for years."

News in the same category

He Bet $100 Million That a Penniless Little Girl Couldn't Play His Unpublished Symphony — Then She Played Every Note by Heart

45 Part