I was fixating. I could feel it. Every time I thought about the glass, my mind went straight to Howard's hands throwing bottles, to the shards on the steps where Max's feet had been, to the eighteen hundred dollars. Anger is a kind of fixation. It narrows everything to a point.
So I made myself do the checklist instead. What do I actually know? One: glass went over the fence for about three weeks. Two: Howard warned me twice about the ground under pools. Three: Sam says his grandfather was trying to protect us. Four: nobody was hurt. Five: I don't know why.
What don't I know? Everything else. What Howard knows. What "the ground isn't right" means. Whether Sam's words were a confession or a misunderstanding. Whether the old man next door is a vandal, a prophet, or something in between.
Olivia came down at five, as she always did, and found me at the table with cold tea. She didn't ask if I'd slept. She could tell.
"Talk to me," she said, pouring coffee.
I talked. I laid out the two diagnoses — he knows something, or he's unwell — and she listened, and then she said the thing that cut through all of it.
"There's a third option, you know."
"What?"
"Both. He could know something and be unwell about it. People don't come in clean categories, Nathan. You of all people should know that — you fly with human beings."
She was right, and I hated how right she was, because it made everything harder. A villain is simple. A sick old man is sad but simple. A man who knows something true and has been driven half-mad by carrying it alone for years — that's complicated, and complicated doesn't fit on a police report.
"Moreno will want to question him," I said. "Once I tell him what Sam said — and I have to tell him, it's evidence — he'll go over there with a notebook. And whatever Howard might have told me freely becomes a statement."
"So go now. Before that. Talk to him as a neighbor, not as a complainant." Olivia reached across the table and took my hand. "And Nathan — listen like you mean it. Not like a pilot running a checklist. Like a neighbor."
"I'll try."
"And one more thing." Her voice went quiet. "If he did this because he thought the pool was dangerous — if he was trying to keep our kids out of it — then we need to know why he thought that. Not just for us. There are seven pools on this street."
Seven pools. I'd counted them myself, walking the block. Seven blue rectangles, seven families, kids swimming every afternoon. If Howard believed the ground under pools was wrong — if he had a reason to believe it, a surveyor's reason — then this wasn't just about my pool anymore.
At seven thirty, I walked across the side yard to Howard's back door and knocked. The morning was already warm — June in Fern Valley, the heat coming on early. Howard's garden was lush along the fence, tomatoes heavy on the vine. I could hear Sam moving around inside, and then Howard's footsteps, slow, and the door opened.
Howard Tate stood there in a flannel shirt with the sleeves rolled up, seventy-one years old, his face gray and tired in a way that had nothing to do with the hour. He looked at me, and I saw in his eyes that he knew exactly why I was there, and that he had been waiting for this knock for three weeks.
"Nathan," he said. "Come in. I've been expecting you."
I stepped inside, and the door closed behind me, and whatever was going to happen next started happening.
Chapter 10: The Kitchen Table
I went to Howard Tate's door the next morning, and I went without the anger I had rehearsed all night, because the anger had burned itself down to something steadier by the time the sun came up. Sam's words had done that. "He was trying to protect us." A sixteen-year-old boy doesn't say a sentence like that about his grandfather unless there is something behind it that is bigger than broken glass.
I stood on my own porch first, coffee in hand, and looked at Howard's house the way you look at a place you've lived next to for six years and never really seen. The paint was holding up. The lawn was cut. There was a wind chime by the front door that I had heard a thousand times without ever registering it as his. Six years of borrowing sugar and waving at the mailbox, and I had never once wondered what Howard Tate did with his evenings.
Olivia found me there. She didn't ask what I was going to say to him. She just said, "Calmly, Nathan. Whatever it is, you get more from calm."
"I know."
"Do you? Because last night you were pacing the kitchen like you wanted to arrest him yourself."
"I was pacing because I didn't know what to do. There's a difference."
She smiled, a small one, and kissed my cheek. "There is. Go find out which one it is."
I walked across the strip of grass between our houses — the grass I mowed, the grass he mowed, the invisible property line we'd never once discussed — and rang his bell. I had no speech prepared, which was probably for the best. Speeches are for people who have already decided what the ending is.