It was a good thought. It was the kind of thought Olivia had that I didn't — the nurse's instinct to gather information before diagnosing. I added it to the list.
Chapter 5: Howard
Howard Tate had lived next door for as long as we had — twenty-two years, the whole life of the subdivision. He was seventy-one, retired, a widower for five years. His wife, Elaine, had died of a stroke in the spring, quick and merciless, and Howard had gone gray in a month. Sam, his grandson, had moved in a year before that, when Sam's mother — Howard's daughter — took a job in another state and decided the boy needed stability more than he needed her. Sam was sixteen now, quiet, good with his hands, polite in the distant way of teenagers who have decided adults are a foreign country.
Howard had been a surveyor. I knew that the way you know things about neighbors — mentioned once at a barbecue, filed away. He had worked for developers, measuring land, marking boundaries, the kind of precise outdoor work that ruins your knees and clarifies your thinking. In retirement he gardened. He grew tomatoes that made Olivia weep with envy and brought them over in paper bags, and he had fixed our sprinkler head last spring without being asked, and he waved at the kids when they got off the school bus.
And twice, he had warned me about the pool.
The first time was last August. We were both at the fence — me skimming the pool, him deadheading roses on his side — and he said, out of nowhere, "You know, Nathan, the ground here isn't right for pools." I laughed. I actually laughed. "It's held up twenty-two years, Howard." He didn't laugh. He looked at the pool, then at the ground under it, then back at me. "Twenty-two years isn't long," he said, and went back to his roses.
The second time was this April. Same fence, same posture — hands in his pockets, eyes on the water. "I'm serious about what I said last summer," he told me. "The ground here isn't right for pools." I was in a hurry that day, late for a trip briefing, and I said something dismissive — "I'll keep an eye on it, Howard, thanks" — and I hurried inside, and I forgot about it before I reached the airport.
Now I stood in my kitchen on a Wednesday morning in June, looking at a pool full of broken glass, and I could not stop hearing his voice. The ground here isn't right for pools.
It was the kind of thing a man says when he knows something you don't. Or the kind of thing a man says when he's losing his grip and fixating on something he can't control. I didn't know which one Howard was. I had liked him for twenty-two years without ever really knowing him, and now I had to find out.
The second warning had been stranger, because of the look on his face. This past April — a Saturday, I was leaving for a four-day trip, rolling my bag to the car — Howard had come to the fence and called my name. Not waved me over. Called my name, like it was important.
"Nathan. I'm serious about what I said last summer. The ground here isn't right for pools."
I was juggling my bag and my crew ID and my phone, and I gave him maybe ten percent of my attention. "I'll keep an eye on it, Howard. Thanks."
"Nathan —"
"Gotta run, Howard. Talk when I'm back."
I had gotten in the car and driven to the airport, and I hadn't thought about it again until this morning. Now I sat at my kitchen table and thought about the set of his jaw that Saturday, the urgency in his voice. That hadn't been small talk. That had been a man trying to tell me something, and I'd blown past him with a suitcase.
What had he been trying to tell me? That the pool would crack? That the deck would sink? That something under the ground was wrong? He was a surveyor — or had been, twenty-five years ago, for some developer whose name I'd never caught. Men who measure land for a living develop a feel for ground the way pilots develop a feel for air. Maybe he'd seen something: a crack in his own patio, a fence post leaning, the subtle settling that happens when fill compacts or water moves underground.
Or maybe — and I had to let this possibility sit on the table too — maybe there was nothing under the ground at all, and the warnings were just the beginning of the same unraveling that ended with bottles over a fence. Seventy-one. Five years a widower. A grandson to raise on a retiree's budget. People break. It happens quietly, and then all at once, and the people around them spend months afterward saying they never saw it coming.
I didn't want Howard to be broken. I wanted him to be the man with the tomatoes. But wanting isn't knowing, and I was done confusing the two.
My phone buzzed. Olivia: Moreno can come at 10:30. I'll be home by then. Then, a second text: Ruby wants to know if she can have friends over this weekend. I told her not at the pool. She's furious at the universe. Normal teenager stuff, on top of everything else.