"You don't have to do that."
"I know I don't have to." She gave me the look — the one that had ended a thousand arguments before they started. "I'm doing it."
That night, lying in bed, she said into the dark, "Do you think it was Howard?"
"I don't want it to be Howard."
"That's not what I asked."
I was quiet for a while. The air conditioning clicked on. Somewhere down the street, a car door closed. "The geometry says the fence," I said finally. "The geometry doesn't say who."
"Sleep," she said. "We'll do geometry tomorrow."
Chapter 4: The Fence
I woke up Wednesday before dawn and went out to the fence with a flashlight, though there was nothing to find in the dark that I couldn't find in daylight. Old habits. A pilot walks the airplane before every flight, even when the last pilot just walked it. You look with your own eyes.
The fence was eight feet of cedar, solid, no gaps. On our side, the deck ran clean to the boards. On Howard's side — I couldn't see Howard's side, but I knew his yard: a vegetable garden along the fence, a shed, the old apricot tree his wife had planted before she died. Sam, his grandson, kept the yard neat. Sixteen-year-olds don't always keep yards neat, but Sam did. He mowed in straight lines.
I stood there in the gray light and tried to picture it. A man — or a boy — standing on the other side of that fence at night, throwing bottles over. Green wine bottles. It would take some strength to clear eight feet of cedar and land in the pool, but not much. A decent arm could do it. The glass would hit the water or the deck or the pool floor and shatter, and the pieces would sink, and in the morning the pool would look almost normal from the house — blue water, floating toys — until you got close enough to see the glitter.
Three weeks. That was the thing I kept coming back to. The glass hadn't all gone in at once. Some of the shards at the bottom had a film on them, a faint slickness that said they'd been in the water a while. Some were bright and sharp-edged, new. Somebody had been doing this for weeks, a little at a time, at night, while we slept thirty feet away.
Olivia found me out there at six thirty with coffee. "The police," she said. "We should call the police."
"I know."
"Today. Not tomorrow."
"Today," I agreed.
She looked at the fence. "Howard wouldn't do this."
"Probably not."
"But you're going to find out."
"Yes."
She handed me the coffee and went back inside to get the kids up for school. I stayed at the fence a while longer. On the other side, I heard Howard's back door open and close, and Sam's voice, low, saying something I couldn't make out, and Howard answering. Normal morning sounds. The thought that one of them had been throwing bottles over my fence at night sat in my chest like a stone.
I called the non-emergency line at eight.
On Howard's side of the fence, I heard the back door open and close, and then water running — Howard filling a bucket for the garden, probably. He gardened the way some men golf: daily, seriously, with strong opinions. His tomatoes were legendary on the street. His roses had won something at the county fair two years running, back when Elaine was alive to arrange them.
Elaine. I hadn't thought about Elaine Tate in a while, and standing at the fence in the gray light, I thought about her now — a small, fierce woman who'd run the neighborhood watch like a military operation and made the best potato salad at every block party for twenty years. Her stroke had been sudden, a Tuesday morning, Howard finding her in the kitchen. The whole street had gone to the funeral. Ruby had cried, which surprised all of us, because Ruby at nine had barely known Elaine — but grief is contagious that way, especially when it's your neighbor's.
After Elaine died, Howard had gone quiet for months. Then Sam moved in — Howard's daughter's boy, sixteen now, all elbows and silences — and Howard had seemed to come back to himself, or at least to a version of himself that gardened and waved and brought tomatoes over. I'd liked watching it, in the distant way you like your neighbors' happiness. It asked nothing of me.
Now I stood at the fence and tried to square the man who brought tomatoes with the geometry of thrown bottles, and I couldn't do it. But I also couldn't unsee the geometry.
I heard Sam's voice then, low, through the boards — "...told you it was too much water" — and Howard answering, "...mind your own business about the water" — and then the back door again. A grandfather and grandson starting their day. I felt obscurely like an eavesdropper, which was ridiculous; it was my own backyard.
I went inside and made coffee, and when Olivia came downstairs I told her I was calling the police at eight. She nodded like she'd expected nothing else, and then she said, "Ask Moreno to talk to Howard too. Not accuse — talk. If Howard knows something, even if he didn't do it, he might have seen something."