thought of the money in the tin box in her room upstairs, the money she had saved, a little at a time, from the hats. She thought of the winter ahead, and the slow months when the hats did not sell, and the coal she would need, and the food. Forty-eight dollars was not a small sum. It was more than a month's trade in the slow season. It was more than she had ever spent on anything at once, except the shop itself.
She did not argue. She did not plead. She did not say that it was unfair, although part of her thought it was, and another part of her thought that it was only business, and that a man who owned a building had a right to ask what the building was worth. She stood behind her counter with her hands flat on the wood, and she looked at him, and she said, "Will you wait a moment? I'd like to show you something."
He nodded, and she went to the back room and brought out the order book. It was a plain book, bound in dark cloth, the pages lined, her handwriting filling them in neat, square lines. She set it on the counter between them and opened it to the current page, and she turned the pages back, one by one, so he could see.
"Twenty-three orders," she said. "Standing now. Not sold and gone — standing, waiting to be made. Straw hats, mostly, this time of year. Some felt, for the autumn. Two dollars to four dollars each, depending on the work. That's my trade, and it doesn't stop. It goes on all year. Winter, summer, it goes on."
He bent over the book and read it, his finger moving down the entries, and Dagny watched his face. She had not planned this. She had not known, when she came downstairs that morning, that he would come, and she had not rehearsed anything. But the order book was there, and the orders were real, and the numbers were true, and she had learned, in the years since her mother died, that the truth, laid out plainly, was the strongest thing a person could bring to a table.
"Twenty-three," he said, and there was something in his voice that had not been there before. Not respect, exactly. But attention. He had come expecting a woman who would argue, or a woman who would agree at once because she was afraid, and he had found neither. He had found a woman with a book full of orders and a steady hand.
"I'm a good tenant," Dagny said. She said it quietly, without heat, because heat would have spoiled it. "I pay on the first of the month. I've never been late. I've never asked you for anything — not a repair, not a favor, not a day's grace. The shop is clean. The rooms are clean. I keep the place up. And my trade is steady. It won't make you rich, but it won't leave you with an empty shop, either. An empty shop earns nothing at all."
He stood up straight and looked at her, and then he looked around the shop — at the hats on their pegs, at the bands of color along the shelf, at the work table in the back with a half-finished hat on it, at the window with the sign turned to face the street. She wondered what he saw. She had been here so long that she no longer saw it the way a stranger would. She saw the work. She saw the years. She hoped he saw what she saw: a shop that was alive, a trade that was real, a woman who would not leave it lightly.
"Twelve is what the street will bear," he said. "I could get twelve from someone else, if you went."
"You could," Dagny said. "But someone else would have to build the trade from nothing, and that takes years. And in the meantime, the shop stands empty, and the roof still needs doing. Twelve from a stranger is a promise. Ten from me is a certainty."
"Eleven," he said. "Eleven, and I'll see to the roof before the first snow."
"Nine," Dagny said. "Nine is what I can pay and still put coal by for the winter and still keep the shop stocked. Nine is honest."