I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The jug sat by my pool equipment for a while, unopened, I think, or opened once and then forgotten. It was not a large object. It did not change the water. It did not change the cost of running the pool in any meaningful way. What it changed was my understanding of Sandra. She was not careless. She was constructing a story in which she was a contributor, and a contributor, in her mind, had rights.

I stopped lending her the benefit of the doubt in June. That is the cleanest way to put it. Before June 21, I had still allowed for the possibility that Sandra did not realize how far things had gone. After the third mention of the $24.99 jug, I no longer allowed for it. She knew. She had simply decided that knowing did not matter, because she had a jug and a story and twelve years of my silence to stand on.

I wrote the entry, closed the notebook, and went inside. The pool was quiet. The jug was by the equipment. The account, as far as I was concerned, did not balance, and it was time to stop waiting for Sandra to balance it herself.

Later that week Doug came on his Tuesday round, as he always did, and left his receipt on the kitchen counter in his plain handwriting. I looked at that receipt beside my note about the $24.99 jug, and the contrast did the arguing for me. One was a single purchase, mentioned three times. The other was twelve years of Tuesdays, fifty-two receipts a year, each one initialed and filed, each one paid by me. His invoices already weighed in. Sandra's jug did not diminish them, and it did not join them. It sat apart, a small fact Sandra had polished until it gleamed, while the real maintenance went on every Tuesday whether anyone mentioned it or not.

Late in June, I sat down to draft the withdrawal letter.

I had never written a letter like it before. I had written plenty of letters in my working life: letters to clients, letters to vendors, letters to the county about permits and assessments, all of them plain and factual and signed at the bottom without flourish. This one was different only in that it was personal, and personal letters are where plainness is hardest to hold. I wanted to be angry in it. I wanted to list everything: the weekdays, the guests, the party, the midnight swimmer, the jug of chlorine mentioned three times. I wanted Sandra to read it and understand, finally, the full weight of what had happened.

I wrote that version first, and then I threw it away. It was too long. It argued. It explained. It gave Sandra sentences she could answer, one by one, and I did not want to give her sentences to answer. I wanted to give her a fact.

So I rewrote it. The second version was shorter, but it still explained too much. It said why I was withdrawing permission, and the why invited debate. A why can be disputed. A why can be called unfair. A why can be met with a different why, and then you are in a correspondence, and a correspondence is a relationship, and I did not want a relationship with this problem anymore.

The third version was shorter still. I cut the history. I cut the grievances. I cut the sentence about the gate code, which I regretted giving and which I was not going to litigate in a letter. What remained was the core: permission, withdrawn, effective immediately. It looked stark on the page. It looked, I thought, like something a person could not argue with without arguing with the idea of permission itself.

I rewrote it a fourth time. This time I changed almost nothing, only a few words, moving them until the sentences sat flat and level, the way a good ledger sits flat. I read it aloud in my kitchen, quietly, to hear whether it sounded like me at my calmest rather than me at my angriest. It did. It sounded like an accountant stating a balance. It did not shout. It did not plead. It did not negotiate, because I had decided, by the fourth draft, that negotiation was the wrong frame entirely. Permission had been mine to give. It was mine to withdraw. That was not a position to be bargained over. It was a fact to be stated.

News in the same category

I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

45 Part