I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

By the end of the week, the grapevine had quieted, as grapevines do when there is no new event to feed it. Sandra did not come to the pool. The gate stayed locked. The pool stayed empty, waiting for plaster work. I went to work, came home, and checked the gate each evening, the way I had checked it all summer. The two versions continued to circulate, one louder than the other, but I had mine written down, and the binder was on the shelf, and I knew which version would survive a reading of the file. That was enough for that week. I did not need the street to agree with me. I needed the record to be complete.

On Friday of that week, I added one more note to the page, because completeness requires it. I wrote that I had heard Sandra's version three times in total, in slightly different wording each time, and that the core of it had not changed: the drain as punishment, the pool as shared, the officers as proof of wrongdoing. I wrote that I had heard the other version twice, and that it had not changed either. I did not write the names of the neighbors who had told me, because they had not asked to be entered into a file, and I saw no reason to make them parties to a dispute that was not theirs. The grapevine, I noted, is not evidence. It is weather. It passes, and what remains after it is the paperwork, the dates, and the locked gate, which do not change their story from one telling to the next.

On the Monday after that week, I called Daniel Okafor. I had his name from Priya, who had used him years earlier for a contract matter and had described him as precise and unhurried. I did not want a lawyer who would make speeches. I wanted a lawyer who would write a letter, correctly, and then tell me what not to do next.

Okafor's office answered promptly, and I explained, briefly, who I was and what I needed. I owned a pool at 14 Cloverfield Road. I had withdrawn permission for a neighbor to use it in writing in July. Use had continued. The pool had since been drained for replastering, and police officers had visited on a Saturday morning. I did not want to file a lawsuit. I said that plainly, twice, because I wanted there to be no misunderstanding about what I was hiring him to do. I wanted a letter, not a lawsuit.

He listened without interrupting, and then he asked for the dates. I gave them to him: July 1, when the letter was mailed; July 3, when it was signed for; August 24, when the child was found in the shallow end; September 2, when Aqua Design quoted the replastering. He asked whether I had documentation of ownership. I said I did, and I listed it, briefly: the Aqua Design contract, the county permit, the final inspection certificate in my name, the two canceled checks, twelve years of maintenance invoices. He did not ask me to read them to him. He asked me to bring copies to his office, or to send them, in order, which I already had.

We met briefly that week, and I brought the copies in a folder, not the binder itself. The binder stayed at home, on the shelf by the front door, because it was the original and I did not lend originals. Okafor reviewed the folder, made notes in a small, neat hand, and told me that a short letter would be sufficient. It would state, in plain language, that I was the owner of record of the pool at 14 Cloverfield Road, that permission to use it had been withdrawn in July, that no further entry for the purpose of using the pool was permitted, and that I would keep records of any further use. It would not threaten a lawsuit. It would not accuse anyone of a crime. It would simply put the position in writing, from a lawyer's office, so there could be no later claim that the position had been unclear.

He sent the letter that week, by mail, to Sandra Fielding at 16 Cloverfield Road. Then he made one phone call to me, to confirm that it had been sent, and to give me one piece of advice. Do not discuss the matter with Sandra directly, he said. Do not argue about the letter at the fence. If there is further use, write it down, as I had been doing, and send him a copy. That was the whole of his advice, and it was the advice I had already been following for seven months, which may be why I trusted him.

News in the same category

I Drained My Pool — Then Karen Returned With The Cops Claiming It Was Hers

45 Part