She introduced herself as a paralegal at a small law firm in town, and she said it in a way that made the job sound like a credential, which, in a sense, it was. She was in her fifties, brisk, well-spoken, with a manner that moved quickly from introduction to familiarity, as if the interval between meeting someone and knowing them were a formality she preferred to skip. Her children were with her, or rather, they trailed behind her in the way children trail behind a parent who is doing the talking: a girl and a boy, small then, curious, polite enough. Maya and Jonah, she said. They were, at that first meeting, simply two small children in a new street, looking at a new neighbor's house with the frank interest children have in any house that is not their own.
I liked her, at first. I want to be plain about that, because it matters to the rest of the story that I did not begin by disliking Sandra Fielding. She was capable. She was organized. She asked about bin days and about the oak at the end of the street and about whether the fence between our yards had ever been a problem. It had not. She laughed easily. She brought a small plant in a pot as a moving-in gift for me, which I put on the kitchen windowsill and watered, dutifully, for longer than the plant deserved. Neighborliness, in those first weeks, felt simple. It felt like the thing a street is supposed to do.
The first summer she lived next door, her children were small and the weather was warm, and the sound of children playing in a neighboring yard is a sound that makes even a private person reconsider her privacy. I could hear them in Sandra's yard, and then, one Saturday afternoon, I could see them from my deck, looking through the fence slats at the blue rectangle in my yard with the unguarded longing children have for water. Sandra was with them. She did not ask, that first time, directly. She remarked, in a light, conversational way, how lovely it must be to have a pool, and how her children had never really learned to swim properly, and how a pool next door was a stroke of luck.
I understood what was being asked, even though it was not quite asked. I understood it, and I considered it the way I consider everything: slowly, and with attention to the edges. I was not opposed to kindness. I was opposed to kindness without edges, because I had seen, in my work and in my life, what happens to an arrangement that has no terms. It spreads. It assumes. It forgets, politely at first and then firmly, that it was ever an arrangement at all.
So I invited them, that first summer, on a Saturday afternoon, when I was home. I invited Sandra's household — Sandra and her two small children — to swim, while I was there, in my own yard, at my own pool. The children were delighted, in the unselfconscious way small children are delighted by water, and they splashed in the shallow end and learned, over several Saturdays, to float and then to paddle and then, triumphantly, to swim a short length without stopping. Sandra sat on the deck with a book she did not read, watching them, thanking me, telling me how generous I was. I accepted the thanks. I did not yet know how expensive it would become.
Those first afternoons were pleasant. That is the truth, and I do not want to rewrite it now to make myself look wiser than I was. The pool was used, the children laughed, Sandra was grateful, and I felt the ordinary, decent satisfaction of having shared something I owned without losing it. I locked the gate when they left. I checked the water on Sunday. Doug came on Tuesday and found nothing amiss. The arrangement held, for a while, because it had edges, and because everyone, for a while, could see where the edges were.
The original permission was spoken, not written, and I have thought about that fact more than any other fact in this story, because it is the fact on which everything else turned. It was given on a Saturday afternoon, in my backyard, in the first summer Sandra lived next door, and it was given in plain language, neighbor to neighbor, without a document, without a witness, without a signature. I said it, and Sandra heard it, and we both nodded, and I believed, as reasonable people believe, that a spoken agreement between adults on a quiet street would hold.
The terms were these. Weekend afternoons only. Rachel home. Sandra's household only. No guests. No keys. No gate code.