"That's arranging," she told him. "That's the whole trade. The tune is yours. The answer is work."
She did not think about whether it was going well. She thought about whether their hands were warm enough — she had started keeping the room's radiator argument as her own private war — and whether the bus driver waited until the last child's coat was zipped, which, on Thursdays, the bus driver now did, because the bus driver was Preston Brandt and Preston had developed, about the zipping of coats and the counting of heads, a dour completeness that the school director described to Elliot, in her monthly report, with the baffled precision of a woman reporting a change in wildlife: *He counts them twice. He knows the lift's moods. The children call him the chair man and he has stopped minding, and I believe he now considers it a title.*
Imani's own protected hours were the mornings — four of them, in writing, before her afternoon classes — and she spent them in the music room at the house, because the carriage house upright was good and the Steinway was the Steinway, and because the piece she was trying to finish had been written by a woman who had corresponded about it in that room's light. She played the twenty-nine bars every morning. She tried the thirtieth bar a hundred ways: bold, plain, borrowed from the hymn settings, borrowed from Catherine's world of recital endings, all architecture and arrival. Every version sounded like a door being shut by somebody else's hand. She wrote them all down and crossed them all out, and the pencil question mark her mother had left over the empty bar began to seem to her less like an invitation and more like a witness: her mother had stood exactly here, at exactly this bar, and had not crossed it either — Bernice Delacroix, who finished everything, who charged extra for weddings because weddings run long, had left this one open with a question mark in pencil, like a woman leaving a porch light on for somebody she could not name.
On the last morning of January, Elliot Brandt came down to the music room while she was working — she heard his step and did not stop playing until the bar, because the contract said *uninterrupted* and because her mother had raised her to finish a phrase for any audience whatever — and stood inside the door with a box in his hands, the archival kind, gray, with a lid, of the sort that holds the parts of a life that somebody has decided to keep properly.
"Catherine's papers," he said. "The foundation's historian asked for them two years ago and I said no, which was not a decision, it was a symptom." He set the box on the piano's closed lid as if it weighed what it weighed. "Her half of the letters are in there. Your mother's hand, mostly — Catherine kept the letters she *received*. Scores, too. I don't know what's in the bottom of it. I've never looked at the bottom of it." He stood a moment with his hand flat on the box, and then took it away, and left it there, and went out of the room with the care of a man leaving a chapel where someone else is praying — and Imani sat with the gray box on the Steinway's lid and her hands in her lap and counted to ten three times before she opened it, because she understood that whatever was at the bottom of it had waited six years in the dark, and could be asked to wait one minute more, while she got her hands warm.
The top of the box was Catherine's world in order: programs tied with ribbon, reviews in sleeves, a recital poster from a hall in Vienna folded so many times the folds had become the paper's grain. Imani lifted it all out with the care of a person handling somebody else's wedding dress, and set it on the piano bench in stacks, and did not read the reviews, because they were not hers to read, and because the letters were underneath.
The letters were in envelopes, forty-one of them, postmarked across two winters and a spring, Detroit to Bloomfield Hills and — these were Catherine's copies, kept in a different hand's order — the drafts of her replies, on her own stationery, unsent versions and sent ones interleaved like the two sides of a conversation overheard through a wall. Imani read her mother's handwriting the way you read a tide table for a coast you grew up on. The early letters were all business and both women pretending it: *Dear Mrs. Brandt, the choir thanks you for the copies of the anthem…* By the fourth they were arguing, gorgeously, about whether a hymn tune is a melody with words or a congregation's memory wearing a melody's clothes. By the ninth Bernice was writing *Catherine* and Catherine was writing back, in the drafts, *Bernice — you are wrong about the third verse and I have been wrong about it at three funerals, so we are even, and here is the voicing you asked for and you will hate the alto line and you will be right.*