There were scores: the "Be Thou My Vision" in both hands, Catherine's pencil over Bernice's ink, *walking figure, slower — B., they are carrying something* and in the margin, in her mother's unsentimental hand, *C. — they are always carrying something. That is the congregation. Keep up.* Imani sat in the silent music room with the pages across her knees and laughed out loud, alone, startled at the sound of it, at the discovery that her mother's wit — which she had known as weather, all her life, the climate of a front room — had been a correspondence too, had had a reader worthy of it, had been *answered*.
At the bottom of the box, under the letters, in a manila envelope gone soft at the corners, were nine loose pages of manuscript in her mother's ink, and the top page was the piece.
She knew it the way you know a face in a crowd you've been dreaming about. The tempo marking: *unhurried, like coming home.* The walking figure, entering transformed — not in a hymn now, but in the piece's own country. Twenty-nine bars. She had carried these bars in the marbled book for six years, had played them a thousand mornings. But these were not the book's pages. These were the *original* — the fair copy her mother had made to send — and this one had things the book did not.
It had a title, at the top, that the marbled book's copy had somehow lost, or that her mother had struck from the copy she kept: *For C., who will know the end of it.*
And it had a tenth page. One page, ruled, with eight bars on it in a hand that was not her mother's.
Imani's hands had gone cold in the warm room. Eight bars: a right hand that reached and a left hand that answered — no. Not answered. *Continued* — the walking figure picked up at a distance, like a second walker joining the first on a road — and above it, in a pencil gone faint, in Catherine Brandt's hand, the hand of the drafts and the margins: *B. — you are doing the thing you accuse the hymns of. You are leaving the last page to the congregation. I have given you the road home. The door is yours — C.*
And the date on the envelope, in Catherine's hand, under the address she had begun and never finished writing — *Bernice Delacroix, Grace Lutheran* — was a date eleven days before Catherine Brandt's death.
Imani read the eight bars at the piano. She played them with the twenty-nine in their place, and the music arrived at the thirtieth bar — the bar with her mother's pencil question mark, the bar that had refused her for two winters and a thousand cold mornings — and stepped through it as through a door that had never been locked at all, only painted to look like wall, and the walking figure went on home with company for eight bars. And then the pages ended, because the eight bars were not an ending: they were a middle. They were one half of a conversation. Catherine had written a road and left the door, and Bernice — widowed of her friend eleven days later, and then, within the year, dead herself at her own piano mid-week — had kept the fair copy and the eight bars and had copied the twenty-nine into the marbled book *without* the title, *without* the tenth page, and put a question mark in pencil at the place where her friend's road arrived at her own unwritten door, and left it there, in the book she marked *for Imani, who hears the ends of things*.
She understood, sitting in the music room with the sun going down the tall windows, a number of things at once, in the order that grief permits: that her mother had not failed to finish the piece — she had been *interrupted*, which is a different thing, and had known it, and had left the interruption in pencil, as information, not weather. That the piece was not a solo with a hole in it. It was a duet for two women in two houses, and one of the players was gone, and the other had gone after her, and the music had been sitting in two boxes — a marbled book in a freezer bag and a gray archive in a billionaire's library — waiting for the two halves to be in the same room again. That she, Imani, was not being asked to answer the question mark like an examiner. She was the third person at the piano. The piece didn't need her to be Bernice, or to be Catherine. It needed her to *play the door* — the part that was left, deliberately, to whoever came next.