She played the thirty-seven bars again, and stopped where the paper stopped, in the middle of the music's sentence, and the room held the unfinished sound the way the fellowship hall had held it on cold mornings — patiently, like a door refusing with the right key missing — except that now she knew whose key it was she was meant to cut.
"You look," said Lawrence Eze, that Sunday, in the fellowship hall, when she told him all of it with the pantry ladies' casseroles steaming in their trays around them and not one of the ladies pretending not to listen, "like a woman whose mother has left her a letter in a locked room and the letter says: *the room was never locked.* Your mother—" he shook his head, with the immense satisfaction of a man whose long charity of an unlatched door has turned out to have been an investment "—your mother once told this church's council that God does not finish our sentences because He is too polite. I told her, Bernice, that is not theology, that is a woman who does not want to finish a piece before the offering. She charged the council extra for the Easter service that year. For the insult." He put a casserole into Imani's hands with the finality of a sacrament. "Eat. You cannot finish a duet on an empty stomach. It is in the Bible. Somewhere in the back, where the maps are."
She drove home to the carriage house in the January dusk with Catherine's eight bars photocopied — Gail had done it, on the house machine, with the air of a woman forging a passport for a head of state — and the marbled book and the fair copy side by side on the passenger seat, in their separate bags, like two halves of a family traveling together for the first time in six years. The alternator turned the engine over without a murmur. She sat a moment in the warm car, in the rich people's garden dark, and listened to it idle: three notes, caught, holding. *The door is yours.* She had a winter's worth of mornings to learn what her door sounded like, and for the first time since she was fifteen, the unfinished thing in her life was not a debt. It was an inheritance with the taxes paid — by two women, in two houses, in pencil and in love — and all of it, all of it, was hers to play.
Dr. Ashe came in February, on a Thursday, because he had telephoned the school director and asked, with the air of a man requesting an audit, to observe the new teacher's beginner class — and because men like Dr. Ashe do not ask to observe beginner classes out of curiosity about beginners. He sat at the back of the storefront recital hall in his overcoat, declining the chair Preston had set for him with the string — he took a folding one of his own choosing, out of a lifetime's suspicion of arranged seating — and he watched Imani teach twelve children their scales and their pieces and their count-before-answering, and he watched Tobias get the cartoon tune answered in a better accent, and at the end of the hour he asked her, in the corridor by the violin wall, the question he had come across the city to ask.
"The conservatory's artist diploma auditions close in April," he said. "There's no fee problem — I want that understood first, and I am aware, having heard you at a certain podium, how it sounds. There are two chairs on the panel who were in that room in November, Miss Delacroix. You would not be walking in as a charity case. You would be walking in as the most interesting unfinished pianist in Michigan." He held up one finger at her expression. "Unfinished is not an insult in my profession. It's the only honest compliment we have."
"You've heard me play two pieces, Dr. Ashe."
"I've heard you play one hymn setting I have thought about every week since November, and one composition of your own that I have thought about oftener, and I have taught pianists for thirty years and I know what training leaves in a pair of hands the way you know—" he gestured at her students, dispersing into the winter dark toward a bus whose driver was counting heads twice "—the way you know what a bus sounds like when it's being driven by a man being reformed. I am not offering rescue. I am offering a door. My profession is doors. I would be ashamed not to knock on yours."