"I'm the piano's landlord," Elliot said. "There's a difference. I learned it this winter."
"The girl plays yours at dawn in a rich man's room and mine at noon in a poor church, and it is the same playing." Lawrence set down the ladle and looked at him with the sympathy of a professional in an adjacent trade. "My wife, before she died, she said a church is not the sermon, it is who gets let in out of the weather. Your wife—" he nodded at Elliot's plate, at the whole arrangement "—she used to send the money for this hall's roof in an envelope with no name, and the council pretended not to know, and I pretended not to know, and the roof pretends water is a rumor. You are sitting in her work, Mr. Brandt. Eat your beans."
On the drive back across the city, in the winter dusk, Imani played the thirty-seven bars in her head for the tenth time that day, and at the thirtieth bar — the question mark, the painted door — she heard, for the first time, not an ending but a *step*: the walking figure, alone, at her mother's tempo, neither hurrying nor mourning, continuing past the place where the company had ended the way a walker continues past the end of a shared road because the road, after all, is also hers. Not a chord. Not an architecture. A step, and then the next one, in the figure her mother had invented for carrying things. She sat up straight in the passenger seat — Tasha was driving, Tasha having declared the Camry's heater a civil rights issue and taken the wheel in protest — and said, "I know how it goes," out loud, to the windshield, in the tone of a woman who has just been handed back a set of keys.
"What goes," said Tasha, not taking her eyes off the road.
"The end of it. It doesn't arrive. It *continues*. All this time I was trying to build a door. It's not a door. Catherine wrote the road, my mother wrote the walking, and the end of it is — the walker goes on, by herself, and it's not sad, it's just — the tempo doesn't change. That's the whole of it. The tempo doesn't change, whether you're accompanied or not. That's what she was teaching in the hymns the whole time and I was too busy *grieving at* the piece to hear it as a lesson."
Tasha drove a block in silence, with the expression of a woman being present at the creation. "Well," she said at last. "Write it down before it gets away. And then, when it's finished, I get a ticket to the rich people's room, and I get to sit in it awake, in a dress I choose, and nobody hands me a tray. Those are my terms. I've been holding them since November, and unlike some people, I negotiate *before* the ovation."
She wrote the ending in March, in the mornings, at the speed of a person learning to walk a road she had been trying to build a door across. It took eleven drafts. The first ten all did what she now understood she had been doing for two winters: they *concluded* — they gathered the walking figure up into chords and cadences, into arrivals with the flags out, into the architecture of other people's endings, conservatory endings, endings that assured the room that the walking was over. She crossed them out with her mother's ruthlessness, in pencil, as information. On the eleventh morning — the radiator ticking in the carriage house below, the thaw beginning its long argument with the garden — she played the thirty-seven bars and let the tempo do what she had heard it do in the church hall, and her hands, which had known the way longer than her mind had, simply went on: the walking figure, alone now, unhurried, the right hand falling silent by degrees until it was only the left hand walking, the way Bernice had started the hymn all those years ago, *a person going somewhere on foot* — and then, in the last bars, the right hand returning, not to answer, not to rescue, but to walk beside, at a distance, in the figure's own stride: the walker, accompanied by her own future, arriving nowhere in particular and completely. It lasted, all told, perhaps ninety seconds. It was so plain that when she finished it she sat in the music room's silence with her hands shaking on her knees, afraid she had merely failed more quietly than usual — and then she played it again, from the top, all of it, the twenty-nine and the eight and the eleven of hers, and at the end of it she was crying with the uncomplicated completeness of a child, because the piece had the property her mother's best hymns had: it did not sound *finished* the way a door sounds shut. It sounded finished the way a road sounds when you can see the house from it.