Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elijah agreed.

That evening, Harlan called again.

I've received the information about the receipt, he said. "Mrs. Brooks sent me a copy."

Do you think it could be important?

It could be. But the name alone does not establish the identity of the buyer or prove that the box contained anything relevant to your father's investigation.

I know.

I want you to keep that in mind. We need to establish the chain of ownership, identify the person who purchased the box, and determine whether any records exist concerning its contents.

Can you do that?

I can request the appropriate records and investigate the leads. I cannot promise what we will find.

Elijah looked at the photograph of the receipt.

Thank you.

The attorney hesitated.

Elijah, I owe you an apology.

The words caught him off guard.

For what?

For dismissing your concerns too quickly. You were right that certain questions had not been examined. That does not mean every theory you have is correct, but it does mean the questions deserve proper investigation.

Elijah swallowed.

I appreciate that.

Your brother is fortunate to have someone who cares enough to keep asking. Just remember that your job is not to prove a theory. It's to help us discover what the evidence actually shows.

I understand.

After the call, Elijah sat quietly at the table.

He had spent days feeling as though he were fighting everyone in the courtroom simply to be heard.

Now, for the first time, the people who understood the law were beginning to take the evidence seriously.

It did not guarantee that Isaiah would be acquitted.

It did not guarantee that the old procurement investigation had anything to do with the assault.

But it meant the case was no longer moving forward on assumptions alone.

Then the telephone rang.

Patricia answered.

A man's voice spoke.

Mrs. Carrington, this is Raymond Tolbert.

Elijah froze.

His mother looked at him.

The judge continued.

I understand that your family has been investigating matters involving Daniel Carrington's old business records.

Patricia tightened her grip on the receiver.

How do you know that?

Because information has come to my attention that may be relevant to the safety of your family and the integrity of the proceedings involving your son.

Which information?

I would prefer to discuss it in person.

Elijah stepped closer.

Your Honor, Patricia said, "my son is standing beside me. You may speak with him."

There was a pause.

Then Tolbert's voice came through the receiver.

Elijah.

Yes, Your Honor.

I want you to stop pursuing the old records.

Elijah felt a cold pressure in his chest.

Why?

Because the matter is unrelated to the charges against your brother, and your investigation may be exposing your family to unnecessary danger.

If it's unrelated, why are you concerned about it?

The line went silent.

Then the judge said, very carefully, "There are circumstances you do not understand."

Then explain them.

I cannot discuss every matter over the telephone.

Can you explain why your name appears on a receipt for a box recovered from my father's truck?

Silence.

Elijah looked at his mother.

She had gone pale.

Finally, Tolbert spoke.

I do not know what document you are referring to.

Then I can send you a copy.

No.

The answer came too quickly.

Tolbert corrected himself.

I mean, that is not necessary. You should provide any potentially relevant material to the appropriate authorities.

Will you answer questions about the receipt if the authorities ask?

Another pause.

That depends on the circumstances.

Elijah felt anger rise.

Your Honor, my father died four years ago. Someone has broken into our house and stolen his letter. My brother is in detention, accused of a crime he says he didn't commit. We have been threatened repeatedly. And now your name appears on a document connected to records my father believed were important.

He took a breath.

I am not asking you to prove anything over the phone. I am asking you not to tell me to stop looking for answers.

The judge's voice became colder.

You are a minor, Mr. Carrington. You do not understand the consequences of what you are doing.

Then help me understand.

I cannot.

Or you will not?

Patricia reached for his arm.

Elijah stopped speaking.

Tolbert continued.

I am advising you to leave the investigation to qualified professionals. Any attempt to interfere with the pending criminal case or to make public accusations without evidence could have serious consequences.

Are you threatening me?

No. I am warning you.

The judge ended the call.

For several seconds, neither Elijah nor his mother moved.

Then Patricia set the receiver down.

That was the judge, she whispered.

Yes.

Why would he call us?

Elijah looked at the receipt.

He did not know.

But he knew one thing with certainty.

Judge Raymond Tolbert had recognized the significance of the investigation before Elijah had even explained all the details.

He had known enough to call the family personally.

And when asked about the receipt, he had refused to discuss it.

Elijah gathered the documents and placed them in a folder.

He did not know whether the judge was protecting himself, trying to protect the family, or warning them about something genuinely dangerous.

He would not decide until he had evidence.

But the phone call had changed everything.

The judge who had laughed when Elijah entered the courtroom was no longer merely a skeptical authority figure.

He was now a person whose name appeared in the investigation.

And whatever the truth might be, Elijah knew that the next step could not be taken carelessly.

The preliminary evidentiary hearing began three days later.

By then, the courtroom had become a place Elijah associated with both fear and determination. The same wooden benches, the same polished floor, the same high windows admitting the bright Georgia sunlight.

But the atmosphere had changed.

The spectators were quieter. The prosecutor no longer smiled when Elijah entered. Harlan arrived with several additional folders, and Isaiah walked to the defense table with a steadiness that had not been present during the first hearing.

Judge Tolbert took his seat without acknowledging Elijah.

The clerk called the case.

Andrea Lindholm rose first.

Your Honor, the State is prepared to proceed with the testimony of the responding officers and the witness who identified the defendant near the scene.

Harlan stood.

The defense is prepared to address the evidence, but we renew our request for clarification concerning the surveillance recording and the circumstances under which the witness revised his statement.

Tolbert nodded.

The court will hear the evidence and address any objections as they arise.

The first witness was Deputy Samuel Grant, the officer who had responded to the gas station.

He testified that he had arrived shortly after 9:30 p.m. and found a man lying near the side entrance. Isaiah had been standing several feet away.

Grant said Isaiah appeared agitated but did not attempt to flee.

Under questioning, the deputy confirmed that he had not seen the assault occur.

He had not recovered a weapon from Isaiah.

He had not observed Isaiah strike the victim.

And he had not personally witnessed Isaiah carrying a dark bag.

Harlan asked about the initial report.

Did you write that the defendant was seen leaving the scene?

Grant reviewed the document.

No. I wrote that he was present when I arrived.

Did you record any statement from the victim identifying the defendant?

No. The victim was unconscious when I arrived.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

30 Part