Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Before we proceed, I want to make several things clear. A criminal defendant has constitutional rights, including the right to represent himself under appropriate circumstances. That does not mean an unlicensed person may automatically act as his attorney. Nor does it mean the court must permit a minor to exercise responsibilities that could compromise the integrity of these proceedings.

Understood, Your Honor.

I have not yet determined whether Mr. Isaiah Carrington's request to represent himself is knowing and voluntary. I will conduct the necessary inquiry. I will also consider whether any limited assistance you propose is legally permissible. Do you understand?

Yes, sir.

Good. Because if you interrupt this court, attempt to practice law without authorization, or engage in conduct that disrupts these proceedings, I will remove you from the courtroom.

Understood.

Tolbert looked toward Isaiah.

Mr. Carrington, I will ask you some questions. You will answer them yourself. Do you understand?

Yes, Your Honor.

The judge proceeded through the standard inquiry.

He asked Isaiah whether he understood the charges, the possible penalties, the disadvantages of proceeding without counsel, and the importance of following the rules of evidence and criminal procedure.

Isaiah answered each question.

When Tolbert asked whether he had received any promises or threats, Isaiah said no.

When the judge asked why he wanted to discharge his appointed attorney, Isaiah hesitated.

I don't believe everything that needs to be examined has been examined, he said.

That is a serious allegation.

I'm not trying to disrespect Mr. Harlan.

Then explain your concern.

Isaiah glanced at Elijah.

I think some of the evidence doesn't match what happened.

Tolbert looked toward the attorney.

Mr. Harlan?

Your Honor, I have reviewed the discovery materials and am prepared to continue representing my client. I have not completed every possible investigative step, but I have acted within the time and resources available.

Do you believe there is a conflict between you and your client?

Not an irreconcilable one, Your Honor.

Isaiah swallowed.

I don't want to lose the right to have somebody look at the evidence just because I can't explain it the way lawyers do.

That sentence quieted the room.

Judge Tolbert removed his glasses.

Mr. Carrington, your ability to explain yourself is not the only consideration. A lawyer can protect your interests in ways you may not appreciate until it is too late.

I understand.

Do you? You may be giving up legal arguments you cannot recover later. You may make statements that can be used against you. You may fail to object to evidence that should have been challenged.

Isaiah's eyes dropped.

Yes, sir.

And your brother cannot simply replace a licensed attorney because you prefer his assistance.

I understand that, Your Honor.

The judge studied him.

Then why are we here?

Isaiah looked toward Elijah again.

This time, his younger brother did not nod or encourage him.

The answer had to belong to Isaiah.

Because I don't want to plead guilty to something I didn't do, Isaiah said. "And I don't want to stand here later wishing I'd asked the questions I was afraid to ask today."

Tolbert was silent for several seconds.

Then he directed the court reporter to record the statement.

I will reserve judgment on the request for self-representation until the court has completed its inquiry. For now, Mr. Harlan remains counsel of record. Mr. Elijah Carrington will not question witnesses, address the court as counsel, or perform any function reserved for a licensed attorney without further authorization.

Elijah nodded.

Yes, Your Honor.

You may remain seated with your brother's permission, but your presence does not confer any special legal status. Is that understood?

Yes, sir.

Very well.

The judge picked up the case file.

We will now address the State's motion concerning the continued detention of the defendant and the scheduling of the preliminary evidentiary hearing.

Elijah sat.

He had not won anything.

His request remained unresolved. His brother still wore restraints. The prosecutor still believed the State could prove its case, and the judge had made it clear that he would not tolerate a teenager pretending to be a lawyer.

But the court had listened.

For now, that was enough.

Then Andrea Lindholm rose.

Your Honor, before we address scheduling, the State wishes to bring an additional matter to the court's attention.

Judge Tolbert looked up.

What matter?

The State received information this morning concerning a possible witness in the case.

Elijah's hand froze over his notebook.

Lindholm continued.

The witness has not yet provided a formal statement. However, the information is sufficiently credible that the State believes it may be relevant to the defendant's motion and the question of continued detention.

Isaiah turned sharply toward his attorney.

Harlan frowned.

What witness? he asked.

Lindholm glanced at the defendant.

An individual who claims to have seen Isaiah Carrington leaving the scene shortly after the assault.

A murmur spread through the courtroom.

Isaiah's face drained of color.

Elijah felt the blood beating in his ears.

Your Honor, Harlan said, rising, "the defense has not received any disclosure concerning this individual."

That is correct, Lindholm replied. "The information was brought to our attention this morning."

By whom?

The identity will be disclosed through the appropriate process.

Harlan objected to proceeding without sufficient notice. The judge listened, asked several questions, and ordered the State to provide the information required by the applicable disclosure rules before the next evidentiary hearing.

But the damage had already been done.

A new witness.

Someone who claimed to have seen Isaiah leaving the scene.

Elijah looked at his brother.

Isaiah was staring straight ahead, his face expressionless in a way that frightened Elijah more than panic would have.

During the recess, Elijah leaned toward him.

Do you know who it is?

Isaiah shook his head.

Are you sure?

Yes.

Did you leave the gas station that night?

No.

Isaiah—

I told you I didn't do it.

I know.

Then why are you asking me like everybody else?

Elijah recoiled slightly.

His brother's anger was not directed entirely at him. It had been building for eleven days, fed by sleepless nights, unanswered questions, and the humiliating experience of watching strangers decide what kind of man he was.

But Elijah could not afford to take the anger personally.

He lowered his voice.

Because I need to know everything, even the things that hurt.

Isaiah stared at him.

Then he looked away.

You don't know everything about that night.

Elijah waited.

What does that mean?

Isaiah's lips parted, but no words came.

Across the aisle, the prosecutor gathered her files. Judge Tolbert spoke quietly with the clerk, and the spectators began leaving their seats.

Isaiah leaned closer.

There are things I haven't told you.

Elijah felt a chill move down his back.

Like what?

His brother looked toward the courtroom doors.

Not here.

Before Elijah could press him, the bailiff approached.

The judge has ordered a recess. The defendant is being returned to detention.

Isaiah stood.

The chains around his ankles rattled.

Elijah gathered his folders, but as he closed the briefcase, a folded piece of paper slipped from between the pages of his father's old codebook.

He caught it before it reached the floor.

The paper was yellowed and brittle, folded into quarters. He had never seen it before.

On the outside, in his father's unmistakable handwriting, were three words.

For my sons.

Elijah stared at the inscription.

His father had been dead for four years.

And whatever was written inside that folded paper had been hidden in the briefcase all along.

Elijah did not open the letter in the courthouse.

He wanted to. The paper seemed to burn against his palm as he walked behind the bailiff, watching Isaiah being led through the security door toward the holding cells.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

30 Part