She was thirty-one years old, a former cashier at the gas station where Robert Gaines had been assaulted. She had left her job several months earlier after a dispute with management and now worked at a grocery store on the outskirts of town.
She had called Patricia twice, but she had never given her full name.
After the second call, she contacted a legal aid attorney and asked whether she could provide information confidentially before deciding whether to make a formal statement.
The attorney arranged a meeting with Harlan's investigator.
Elijah was not present.
He learned about the meeting from Harlan the following afternoon.
Rachel Dorsey says she saw Victor Sloane at the gas station on the night of the assault, the attorney explained. "She also says she heard him arguing with Daniel Pike."
Elijah gripped the phone.
What were they arguing about?
She says Pike was demanding money. Sloane told him that the arrangement had changed and that he should stop asking questions.
Did she hear anything about Isaiah?
Not directly. But she says Sloane mentioned a man who had been asking about old records.
Elijah's thoughts returned to the blue ledger.
Did she hear my father's name?
She believes Sloane said 'Daniel,' but she cannot be certain whether he meant your father or another person.
Did she see the assault?
She heard shouting and then saw Robert Gaines on the ground. She did not see the actual blow.
Elijah felt both hope and frustration.
Rachel's statement might help explain the circumstances surrounding the assault, but it did not establish who had attacked Gaines or why.
What happens now?
We will document her account, determine what can be corroborated, and provide the required information to the prosecution. The court will decide what evidence may be considered.
Is she safe?
Harlan paused.
She is concerned about retaliation. We have advised her to report any threats and avoid contact with anyone involved in the case.
Elijah thought of the woman who had called his mother.
Did she receive threatening messages?
She says she received one anonymous message after leaving the gas station. It told her to forget what she had heard.
Elijah closed his eyes.
The pattern was becoming clearer.
People who knew something were frightened into silence. Witnesses changed their statements. Records disappeared. A man had been assaulted outside a gas station, and Isaiah had been summoned there under the promise of information about his father's records.
But the pattern still did not establish who had attacked Gaines.
Nor did it prove that Victor Sloane had orchestrated the assault.
Elijah wrote down the information.
Then he added a question.
What was Robert Gaines arguing about before the attack?
Harlan said the victim had begun to remember more details, though his account remained incomplete.
He recalls an argument about a document, the attorney said. "He believes someone wanted him to hand over a piece of paper. He does not know whether it was connected to the old procurement investigation."
Elijah felt his pulse quicken.
A document?
Yes.
Could it have been part of the ledger?
Possibly. But we cannot assume that.
Elijah looked at the photograph of the blue pickup.
The missing box.
The old records.
The argument.
The assault.
The pieces seemed to be moving toward one another, but the final connection remained elusive.
Can I speak to Rachel? he asked.
No.
Elijah stiffened.
Why?
Because she is a potential witness, and direct contact could create problems for her and for your brother's case. I am not going to permit you to interview her or influence her testimony.
I wasn't going to—
I know you want answers. But this is where you have to trust the process.
Elijah swallowed.
All right.
After the call, he sat at the kitchen table for a long time.
He was beginning to understand the limits of his role.
He could organize information, preserve records, identify contradictions, and help his family ask the right questions.
But he could not replace investigators, interview witnesses without consequence, or turn every suspicion into a confrontation.
The case had become too important for improvisation.
That evening, Mrs. Brooks visited the house.
She found Elijah surrounded by papers.
You look exhausted, she said.
I am.
Then take a break.
I can't.
Yes, you can.
He looked up.
What if we miss something?
What if you make a mistake because you're too tired to see what is in front of you?
Elijah said nothing.
Mrs. Brooks sat beside him.
You have done more than most people your age would know how to do. You have helped your brother's attorney identify questions that deserved investigation. You have preserved evidence. You have learned to distinguish facts from assumptions.
She tapped the notebook.
But you cannot keep carrying the entire case in your head.
Elijah stared at the pages.
I don't know how to stop.
You don't have to stop caring. You have to stop believing that caring means you must work every minute.
She gathered several loose papers and placed them into a folder.
Tonight, you are going to eat dinner with your mother. You are going to sleep. Tomorrow, you can continue.
Elijah almost protested.
Then he looked at the dark circles beneath her eyes and realized she was right.
He had been treating exhaustion as proof of dedication.
It was not.
He closed the notebook.
For the first time in days, he allowed himself to sit at the table without reading a document.
His mother served dinner.
They talked about school, the house repairs, and the possibility of Isaiah returning home before the end of the year.
Patricia did not promise that everything would be fine.
She simply listened.
And for a few hours, Elijah was allowed to be seventeen.
The next morning, Harlan called with news.
The original surveillance footage had been located.
The gas station's manager had kept a backup drive containing recordings from several cameras. The drive had not been part of the initial disclosure because it had been stored in an off-site office after the station changed ownership.
The prosecutor had agreed to preserve the drive and arrange an independent examination.
Elijah felt a surge of excitement.
Does it show the assault?
We don't know yet.
Can it show who was there?
Possibly. The recording quality is limited, and the cameras may not cover every angle. But it could help establish the sequence of events.
Will the defense be allowed to examine it?
Yes, subject to the court's procedures. We have requested access through the appropriate process.
Elijah looked toward the window.
For the first time, he could imagine a path through the confusion.
The original footage might establish when Isaiah arrived, whether he spoke with Pike or Sloane, and whether another person approached the victim.
It might also reveal nothing useful.
But at least the question would be answered by evidence rather than speculation.
The examination took several days.
During that time, Harlan continued investigating the old storage records, and the prosecutor's office reviewed Rachel Dorsey's statement.
Elijah attended school, completed his assignments, and tried to follow Mrs. Brooks's advice about rest.
He still checked his phone too often.
He still woke at night thinking about the stolen letter.
But he no longer tried to solve every problem alone.
When the report finally arrived, Harlan called the family to his office.
Patricia and Elijah sat across from him while he opened a folder containing the preliminary findings.
The recording does not show the actual assault clearly, he said. "One camera captures the side entrance, but a parked truck blocks part of the view. Another camera covers the parking area."
Elijah leaned forward.