For the first time, Isaiah lowered his eyes.
He had heard his younger brother say those words before, though never in a courtroom. Elijah had said them at their kitchen table three weeks earlier, while Isaiah sat with his head in his hands and the police reports spread across the table between them.
Back then, Isaiah had dismissed him.
He had told him to concentrate on school, keep his head down, and stop pretending he could fix every broken thing in their family.
Now the boy stood before a judge in a suit that belonged to their dead father, asking the court to examine a case that could send his brother to prison.
Judge Tolbert tapped the papers against his desk.
Mr. Carrington, this court will not allow a teenager to turn a criminal proceeding into a performance.
Neither would I, Your Honor.
A few spectators shifted in their seats.
The judge's eyes narrowed.
Careful.
Yes, sir.
Tolbert looked toward the defense table.
Mr. Isaiah Carrington, stand.
Isaiah rose. The chain between his ankle restraints made a faint metallic sound.
Did you file this motion?
Yes, Your Honor.
Did you ask your brother to represent you?
Isaiah hesitated.
Elijah did not turn around.
Answer the question, the judge ordered.
Yes, sir.
Do you understand that you have a right to an attorney? That if you cannot afford one, the court may appoint counsel to represent you? And that proceeding without a licensed attorney can have serious consequences?
Yes, sir.
Has anyone threatened you, pressured you, or promised you anything to make you request self-representation?
No, sir.
Tolbert studied him.
Isaiah was twenty-four years old, broad-shouldered, and exhausted. A faded scar ran along his left eyebrow, and his workman's hands were clasped awkwardly in front of him. He had spent the past eleven days in the county detention center, sleeping beneath fluorescent lights and trying to understand how a single night could destroy everything he had spent years building.
Why would you want to represent yourself? the judge asked.
Isaiah looked at Elijah.
For the first time that morning, the younger boy turned fully toward him.
There was no accusation in his expression. Only an unspoken question.
Isaiah swallowed.
Because I don't think my appointed lawyer has seen everything, he said.
The attorney beside him stiffened.
Your Honor, the lawyer began, "I have reviewed the discovery provided by the State."
And I appreciate that, Mr. Harlan, Tolbert replied. "But your client appears to be raising concerns about his representation. We will address those concerns in an orderly fashion."
Isaiah nodded.
Tolbert turned back to Elijah.
That still does not establish that you may practice law.
I understand.
Do you have any legal training?
No formal training, Your Honor.
Then tell me why I should permit you to participate in these proceedings.
Elijah looked down at the briefcase.
The leather had split along one corner. A thin line of pale stitching held the damaged seam together. His father had repaired it himself during the final winter of his life, sitting at the kitchen table while the family's old heater rattled and a pot of soup simmered on the stove.
Elijah remembered the needle passing through the leather. He remembered his father's large hands, the patience with which he worked, and the words he had spoken when Elijah asked why he bothered repairing something so old.
Because, his father had said, "something being damaged doesn't mean it's worthless."
Elijah lifted his eyes.
I'm not asking the court to ignore the rules, Your Honor. I'm asking the court not to decide what I'm capable of before it examines what I've brought.
The judge stared at him.
For several seconds, neither man spoke.
Then Tolbert leaned toward the court reporter.
Mark the documents as received for review. We will take a short recess to determine the appropriate procedure.
The gavel struck once.
Fifteen minutes.
The courtroom erupted into whispers.
Elijah returned to the defense table and began arranging his folders. His hands were steady until he reached for the copy of the Georgia Code. Then his fingers trembled slightly, and he pressed his palm against the cover until the shaking stopped.
Isaiah leaned toward him.
Little brother.
Elijah continued aligning the papers.
You shouldn't be here.
Probably not.
I'm serious.
So am I.
Isaiah's voice dropped.
Do you even know what you're doing?
Elijah finally looked at him.
I know what they say happened.
That's not the same thing.
No. It isn't.
Isaiah glanced toward the spectators, then toward the attorney who had moved several feet away to speak with the prosecutor.
You think you can walk in here wearing Dad's suit and make everybody listen?
Elijah's jaw tightened.
No.
Then why?
Because somebody has to ask the questions nobody else is asking.
Isaiah shook his head.
You are seventeen.
And you're my brother.
For a moment, Isaiah seemed unable to answer.
Then he lowered his voice further.
Elijah, listen to me. Whatever happens in this room, don't let them turn you into another person they can break.
Elijah looked at the restraints around his brother's ankles.
You first.
Isaiah closed his eyes.
Across the aisle, Judge Tolbert disappeared through the side door leading to his chambers. Andrea Lindholm remained at her table, reading the motion again with a seriousness that had replaced her earlier amusement.
Elijah opened the worn codebook.
On the inside cover, in faded blue ink, his father had written a sentence that Elijah had memorized long before he understood its meaning.
The truth does not become less true because the person speaking it is young.
He ran his thumb over the handwriting.
Then he turned to the first marked page.
He had fifteen minutes.
And the first thing he needed to prove was not that his brother was innocent.
It was that the court had not yet heard the whole story.
Fifteen minutes was not enough time to prepare for a courtroom battle.
It was barely enough time to remember how to breathe.
Elijah sat at the defense table with the Georgia Code open before him, reading the same paragraph for the third time. The words had not changed, but his understanding of them seemed to grow less certain with every passing second.
He knew the statutes. He knew the sequence of events that had brought his brother to court. He knew the statements the police had taken, the evidence they claimed to possess, and the questions nobody had answered.
What he did not know was how much authority Judge Tolbert would allow him to exercise.
And that uncertainty frightened him more than he wanted to admit.
You're going to get yourself into trouble, a voice whispered.
Elijah looked up.
Martin Harlan, Isaiah's court-appointed attorney, stood beside the table with a thick file tucked beneath one arm. He was in his early fifties, with thinning gray hair, tired eyes, and a loosened tie. His suit was expensive enough to suggest that he had once cared about his appearance, but the frayed cuffs and scuffed briefcase told a different story.
He had been practicing criminal defense for nearly twenty years. He had represented shoplifters, drug dealers, desperate fathers, frightened teenagers, and men whose guilt had been obvious before they entered the courtroom.
He had also lost cases he believed he should have won.
Those losses had taught him that the law could be unforgiving, particularly to people who lacked money, influence, or the patience to understand its machinery.
Mr. Harlan, Elijah said.
Don't call me that as though we're colleagues.
I'm not trying to insult you.