Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then stop making this harder than it needs to be.

Harlan pulled out the chair beside him and sat down. His eyes moved over the open codebook, the three folders, and the handwritten notes.

Where did you learn to prepare motions?

Reading.

Reading what?

Statutes. Court decisions. Public filings.

On the internet?

Some of them.

Harlan rubbed his forehead.

Lord help us.

Elijah said nothing.

The attorney opened the top folder and began scanning its contents. At first, he appeared irritated. Then he reached a page containing a list of evidence requests and stopped.

Who prepared this?

I did.

Harlan turned another page.

And this?

Me.

He stared at a handwritten timeline in which the movements of the police officers had been arranged by time, location, and source of information.

This is your work?

Yes, sir.

How long have you been doing this?

Since Isaiah was arrested.

Eleven days?

Yes.

Harlan looked at the boy for a long moment.

Do you understand how much you don't know?

Probably more than you think.

That's not an answer.

It's the only honest one I have.

The attorney leaned back.

For an instant, Elijah thought he might laugh. Instead, Harlan's expression softened, revealing something close to pity.

Your brother is in serious trouble. The State has a witness, a weapon, and physical evidence. The prosecutor is experienced. The judge has little patience for theatrics. You walk in here without a license, without experience, and without an adult who understands what you're trying to do. Even if every suspicion you have turns out to be correct, you could damage your brother's case before anyone gets the chance to investigate them.

Elijah looked toward Isaiah.

His brother was staring at the floor, his shoulders rounded beneath the detention center's orange uniform.

What would you do if you thought the evidence was wrong? Elijah asked.

I would challenge it.

Have you?

Harlan's mouth tightened.

I've done what I could with the information available to me.

Did you request the original surveillance recordings from the gas station?

I requested the footage the State disclosed.

That's not what I asked.

The attorney's eyes hardened.

No. I haven't requested the original recording from the station's owner. The State provided an extract from the camera system.

Did you ask for the dispatch audio?

I received the incident report.

Did you listen to the audio?

Harlan did not answer immediately.

Elijah waited.

Finally, the attorney said, "Not yet."

Did you interview the witness who called the police?

I reviewed her statement.

Did you ask her what she saw before she made the call?

Harlan closed the folder.

That's enough.

Elijah lowered his eyes.

He had expected resistance. What he had not expected was the hollow feeling spreading through his chest.

He had hoped Harlan would explain why the unanswered questions did not matter. He had hoped there was some professional reason the most obvious gaps had been left untouched.

Instead, the attorney had confirmed what Elijah feared.

Some of the questions had never been asked.

Listen carefully, Harlan said. "Your brother may have made a mistake in choosing to proceed without counsel. You may have made an even bigger mistake by encouraging him. If the judge rejects your request, let it go. Do not argue. Do not embarrass yourself. And whatever happens, do not interfere with my responsibilities."

Elijah looked up.

Are you still his attorney?

For now.

Then you should be asking those questions.

Harlan's face reddened.

Before he could respond, a woman's voice came from behind them.

Mr. Harlan is right about one thing.

Andrea Lindholm stood at the end of the table, holding a copy of Elijah's motion.

Your brother's case is not a school project.

Elijah rose.

Good morning, Ms. Lindholm.

She seemed momentarily surprised by the courtesy.

Do you know why I came over here?

No, ma'am.

Because I wanted to see whether the boy who filed these documents understood what they meant.

I understand what they request.

That isn't the same as understanding what they mean.

You're right.

Her eyes narrowed slightly.

It was not the response she expected.

Elijah continued. "That's why I asked the court to review them."

Lindholm placed the papers on the table.

Let me give you some advice. Your brother has been charged with armed robbery and aggravated assault. A man was injured during the incident. There is testimony identifying Isaiah, and the State believes it can prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. This is not a situation where a clever argument makes the evidence disappear.

What evidence would you say is strongest?

She stared at him.

Excuse me?

If you had to choose one piece of evidence that most strongly establishes Isaiah was responsible, what would it be?

Lindholm's expression became cold.

I don't discuss trial strategy with defendants' relatives.

Of course.

And I certainly won't discuss it with someone who may not even be permitted to sit at the defense table.

She turned to leave.

Elijah spoke before he could reconsider.

Then you won't mind if the court examines the original recordings.

Lindholm stopped.

Slowly, she turned back.

What recordings?

The gas station security footage. The incident happened outside the station, according to the police report. Your evidence disclosure includes a short video clip, but not the original recording or the complete footage from the surrounding cameras.

The prosecutor said nothing.

Elijah opened the second folder and removed a sheet.

The police report says the incident was reported at 9:17 p.m. The video file metadata indicates the clip provided to the defense was exported at 10:42 the following morning. The report also references an officer reviewing surveillance footage at 9:39 p.m., before the store owner officially provided the recording.

Lindholm reached for the page.

Elijah handed it to her.

Where did you get this?

From the discovery materials.

Who showed you the metadata?

I examined the file information.

You know how to examine digital evidence?

Enough to recognize when a question needs an expert.

For the first time, Lindholm seemed to study him rather than merely look at him.

You should be very careful about making accusations you cannot support.

I'm not accusing anyone of anything.

You're suggesting the police mishandled evidence.

I'm suggesting there are questions about the recording's origin and completeness.

Those are matters for counsel.

Then I hope counsel asks them.

The words were polite.

Their meaning was not.

Lindholm gathered her papers.

You may be intelligent, young man, but intelligence without experience can be dangerous. You don't know what you don't know.

I agree.

She paused, as though waiting for him to add something.

He did.

That's why I keep asking questions.

For a moment, the prosecutor's expression changed. Beneath the professional irritation, Elijah glimpsed something that looked almost like recognition.

Then she turned and walked away.

Harlan watched her go.

Do you enjoy making enemies? he asked.

No, sir.

You're remarkably good at it.

I'm trying to find out what happened to my brother.

Sometimes those things are not the same.

Elijah closed the folder.

Maybe they should be.

Across the courtroom, the bailiff called everyone to order.

Judge Tolbert had returned.

The spectators rose, and the room settled into silence. The judge took his seat, adjusted his glasses, and looked down at the documents.

I have reviewed the initial filing, he announced. "The court has serious concerns about the legal sufficiency of the request and the proposed role of the defendant's brother."

Elijah stood.

Yes, Your Honor.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Teen in Court — Then Discovers He’s a Genius Attorney!

30 Part