"It shouldn't sit at the end of a hall where nobody's allowed to touch it," she had told him. "It's not that kind of piano. Mr. Lindqvist played it in hotel bars. It needs people."
There is a small brass plate on its case now, beside the music desk, just above the little chip in the wood that nobody has ever fixed. It is engraved with three names, one above the other, and three sets of dates.
ERIK LINDQVIST. HELENA VANCE. CLARA VANCE.
There is room underneath for more.
* * *
Clara played her mother's piece for the second time in public on the twelfth of December the following year, at her first recital at the conservatory, in the small hall on the second floor, on Mr. Lindqvist's piano. The hall seats one hundred and twenty. It was full. Anton Reiss sat in the front row with his stick hooked over the seat in front of him, and when she walked out onto the stage barefoot, in a plain black dress, with her shoes left neatly side by side in the wings, he laughed out loud with delight, and several people turned to look at him, and he did not care.
She played Bach first. Then Chopin. Then Schumann. And then, last of all, she played a piece that was not printed in the programme, that the programme listed only as Nocturne, by H. Vance. When she reached the end of it, the walk home in the dark, the single high A, the hall was so silent that you could hear the radiators ticking.
Julian Ashcroft was not in the front row. He was at the very back, standing against the wall by the door, in a plain dark coat, alone. He had not told her he was coming. He did not stay for the reception afterwards. But she saw him, as she rose from the bench and turned to the audience. Their eyes met across the hall, for the third time. He did not smile. Neither did she. He simply inclined his head, very slightly, the way some of the guests at Halcourt had done as she walked past them barefoot. Then he went out quietly through the door before the applause had finished.
He did not go back to Halcourt that night. He drove instead to a narrow street on the west side of the city, a street of terraced houses with small front gardens, and parked outside one of them, and sat in the car for a while with the engine running and the heater on.
The house belonged to a retired music teacher named Mrs. Okonkwo, who had placed a small advertisement in the community newspaper. Piano lessons, all ages, all levels, beginners welcome. Reasonable rates. He had cut it out and kept it in his wallet for three months, folded, like a receipt.
He had been going every Tuesday evening since September.
He was not very good. He was fifty-seven years old and his fingers were stiff and he had forgotten nearly everything Mrs. Albrecht taught him forty-six years before. His left hand was slow and his right hand rushed. He could not keep his shoulders down. He sometimes sat at Mrs. Okonkwo's small upright piano, which had yellowed keys and a metronome on top of it shaped like a pyramid, and struggled with a simple minuet that a child of nine could have played, and felt his face burning with something very like shame, and wanted to get up and walk out into the street and never come back.
He never walked out.
He turned off the engine. He got out of the car. He went up the short path through the small front garden, past a bare rosebush with a few dry leaves still clinging to it, and rang the bell. And when the door opened, and he had taken off his coat, and his shoes, and sat down on the bench with his feet bare on the cold brass of the pedals, which Mrs. Okonkwo had found very strange the first time but had stopped commenting on by the second, he put his stiff hands on the keys and played the first eight bars of the minuet, and got the fifth bar wrong, as he always got the fifth bar wrong.
Mrs. Okonkwo, sitting beside him in her cardigan with her reading glasses pushed up into her grey hair, did not sigh. She did not frown. She did not tell him that was enough of that.
"Again," she said.
And Julian Ashcroft, who owned office towers in four cities and pieces of a dozen more, who had been given everything in the world that could be counted and had learned too late that the things that mattered most could not be counted at all, took a breath, and straightened his back, and lowered his shoulders the way he was learning to, and put his hands back on the keys.
He began again.