This was a source of endless amusement to the children who came for lessons. Mrs. Vance's feet were always bare, summer and winter, on the pedals of the big black piano. Helena said it was because Mr. Lindqvist had taught her that way. He used to say that a pianist who wore shoes was like a painter who wore gloves. You had to feel the pedals. You had to feel the floor, the way the sound came up through the wood and into your heels. The piano was not just something you touched with your hands, he said. You touched it with your whole body. Clara had played barefoot too, from the very beginning. She had never known any other way. Her feet on the cold brass of the pedals, her toes curling slightly when she pressed the sustain. It was as natural to her as breathing.
Then, two years ago, her mother had started getting tired.
At first it was just tiredness. Helena laughed about it, blamed the winter, blamed the students, blamed getting older. Then there were the bruises that would not fade, and the night sweats, and the afternoon she fainted in the kitchen with a pan of soup on the stove, and Clara came home from school to the smell of burning and her mother on the floor. The hospital. The tests. A doctor with very kind eyes and a voice that was too careful. A word that Clara had looked up on her phone in the hospital corridor and then wished she had not.
They did not have good insurance. They had the kind of insurance you have when you teach piano to neighbourhood children at fifteen dollars an hour, which is to say they had very little. The bills came quickly and then they came faster. Helena sold her mother's jewellery. She sold the car. She remortgaged the house on Fenwick Road, which had been paid off for thirty years, and then she could not make the payments on the new mortgage. Clara left school in the middle of her final year and got a job at a supermarket, stacking shelves on the night shift, and then a second job washing dishes at a diner on Harmon Avenue in the mornings, and still it was not enough. It was never going to be enough. The numbers were too big. Clara would lie awake doing arithmetic in the dark and it never came out right.
Her mother would not sell the piano. Clara had suggested it once, in the worst of the winter, very gently, sitting on the edge of the hospital bed. She had thought her mother would be angry. Instead Helena had just looked at her for a long time, and then she had said, quite calmly, "No. Not while I'm alive. That piano is the only thing I have to give you."
So it was not sold while she was alive.
In the last weeks, when Helena could no longer get out of bed, Clara moved the bed into the front room, right beside the piano. It took her and a neighbour a whole afternoon. Then every evening Clara sat at the long black bench and played for her mother, everything she knew, everything her mother had taught her, and Helena lay with her eyes closed and her thin hands folded on the blanket and sometimes moved one finger very slightly, keeping time. Sometimes she would say "slower" or "the left hand, darling, listen to the left hand." Sometimes she would say nothing at all and Clara would look over and see tears running quietly down into her mother's hair.
Three weeks before the end, Helena asked Clara to bring her a pencil and the old manuscript book from the piano stool.
The manuscript book was the one with the faded red cover. Clara had seen it all her life but had never been allowed to look inside. It held her mother's own compositions, the ones she had written over the years and never played for anyone. Helena opened it on her lap and turned the pages slowly, and stopped at one near the back, and Clara saw that it was covered in pencil, notes and crossings-out and little arrows, her mother's handwriting dense and quick across the staves.
"I started this the week you were born," Helena said. "I never finished it. I could never get the ending right."
She worked on it for three days. Clara would come home from the diner and find her mother propped on her pillows with the book on her knees and the pencil in her hand, her lips moving, sometimes humming very faintly under her breath. Sometimes she asked Clara to play a few bars on the piano so she could hear them. Sometimes she would listen and shake her head and rub something out. On the third evening she closed the book and held it against her chest for a while and then gave it to Clara.