Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Whitaker asked two more questions, received the same calm in answer, and rang off to call the store, which — Simone learned later — told her it did not comment on customer matters. Silence, Simone thought, is also a comment, and it rarely lands on the powerful.

Simone spent the rest of the morning the way she spent any morning when a thing could not be hurried: she made the calls that were actually hers to make. She told the foundation's board chair herself, in five factual sentences, before the story could reach her in a worse shape. She told her research deputy that Monday's schedule stood unchanged. She did not call anyone from the store, and she did not call Caroline Whitmore, whose number she did not have and would not have used. Discipline, in her experience, was mostly the art of refusing the satisfying action in favor of the useful one, and the satisfying actions available that morning — anger, rebuttal, a statement issued hot — were none of them useful.

By noon the foundation had heard, the way foundations hear: a board member's spouse, a gala sponsor asking, with great delicacy, whether there was "anything they should know." Dr. Rachel Nguyen, the foundation's chief operating officer, arrived at Simone's house at two with a folder, two coffees, and the expression of a friend performing triage.

"Facts first," Rachel said, settling at the table where Simone's own file already lay in order. "Then we decide what, if anything, the foundation says, and it will be one short statement, once, and it will be boring. No public war. A war is what she wants; it makes her version a side, and she doesn't have a side, she has a story she told at a club."

They worked through it as colleagues, which was also how they were friends. The gala was next Saturday. Maya would receive the Young Advocate Award. Caroline Whitmore, Rachel noted without pleasure, sat on the gala's host committee, as she had for years — a woman who had raised money for Simone's foundation across a dozen ballrooms without ever learning the name of the woman who directed it. They agreed: the committee would be told nothing yet, the gala would proceed, and no decision about Caroline would be made in anger or in public. "She gets handled by process," Rachel said. "Like everything else that has ever tried to knock this place sideways."

Rachel stayed for another hour, working the practical list. The foundation's statement, if it became necessary, would confirm only that Dr. Bennett directed the foundation, that the police had found no evidence, and that the foundation did not conduct its business in comment threads. Sponsors would be answered by Simone personally, briefly, and once. Maya's award would not become the story's illustration; no photographs of the dress would be offered to anyone. "We starve it," Rachel said. "Carefully, and with better paperwork than theirs."

The last call of the day was Simone's to make, and she had known since the drive home that she would make it.

Adrienne Cole answered her own phone. Fifty-five, a civil litigator with a reputation for cases won on documents rather than volume, she listened to Simone's account without a single interruption, and then asked for the things Simone already had in her folder: the incident printout, Elena's written account of the finding, the times. "Send me everything, including the video," Cole said. "Do not post anything. Do not correct anyone online. From here, every true thing gets said once, in the right room, with a record attached."

"And if she keeps talking?" Simone asked.

"Then she keeps making our case for us," Cole said. "But let's hope she is better advised than that."

Neither of them, hanging up, believed she would be.

The apology arrived on Monday, and it arrived the way such things are designed to arrive: deniably, at one remove, wrapped in other people's voices.

Richard Whitmore telephoned the store. The store telephoned Simone — not Elena, who had been instructed to let management handle "the relationship," but Castellano himself, warm as a brochure. There had, he said, been a conversation. The Whitmores regretted the unpleasantness of Saturday. Mrs. Whitmore had acted, he was sure Simone would understand, out of a genuine concern for the store she loved. If anyone had been offended by how matters unfolded, she was sorry for that. Perhaps, going forward, everyone could simply—

"Stop there," Simone said, gently, because gentleness cost her nothing and she had decided to spend it only where it was true. "I want to be sure I understand what is being offered. Is Mrs. Whitmore sorry that she accused me of a theft I did not commit?"

A pause assembled itself on the line. "I think she'd say the situation escalated beyond anyone's intention—"

"That is not what I asked."

What was being offered, once the wrapping came off, was an apology with no act inside it: regret for an atmosphere, sorrow for a feeling, concern for a store. The word theft did not appear. The word wrong did not appear. Simone's name, in the draft Castellano haltingly described, did not appear either. It was a document built to be described later as an apology by the people who had offered it and to be unrecognizable as one by the woman it was for.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part