Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Harlan spelled his name with the air of a man humoring a formality. Elena gave hers quietly and wrote as Simone spoke: the time of the stop, 3:31; the location; who was present. Simone asked for the basis of the accusation in plain language, and Harlan said a customer had reported a white blouse missing from the fitting rooms and that she had been observed leaving with fewer garments than she had taken in.

"I took three garments into fitting room four," Simone said. "A blue dress, a burgundy gown, and a white blouse. I tried on the blouse. I decided against it. I left it hanging on the hook inside the door. I brought out the dress and the gown. The gown I put back on its rack myself. That is the whole of it, and it can be checked in one minute by walking down the corridor and opening the door of room four."

"We're conducting an inventory," Harlan said.

"Then conduct it. But first—" She nodded at the handbag on the desk. "You intend to search this. I am telling you there is nothing of this store's in it except what I have paid for, and I have the receipt in the side pocket for the suit I bought today. I will open it myself, item by item, in front of these witnesses, because I will not have it said later that anything was found or not found out of anyone's sight. Understand me: I am not consenting because you have the right. I am doing it so that the record of this room is exact."

She opened the bag herself. Wallet. Phone. A paperback with a broken spine. Keys on a plain ring. A folded printout of the gala seating draft, which she had been annotating in fifteen-minute increments of thought all week. The receipt for the suit, which Elena confirmed aloud for the notebook. A lip balm. Nothing else. She turned the lining pockets out, one and then the other, with the methodical air of a surgeon closing, counting instruments as she went.

Harlan had the associate pat the sides, check the purchases in the matte black bag — the suit, the white blouse that was part of it, the narrow tie, all receipted — and the blue dress draped over the chair, which still bore its tag and sensor because Simone had not yet paid for it, because she had been on her way to the registers to pay for it when she was stopped.

Nothing was found. The sentence formed in the room and nobody said it, because saying it would have required someone to take responsibility for what came next.

Megan, from her place by the door, said it instead, quietly. "For the record — there's nothing in Dr. Bennett's bag that belongs to the store." Elena wrote it down as it was spoken, with the time beside it, and Megan watched her write it: a true thing, now in ink, where it could not be unsaid for her.

Simone repacked her bag slowly, each item to its place. "I want a copy of the incident report when it's written," she said. "I want the name of the customer who accused me — no. You won't give me that. Then I want it recorded that I asked. I want everything you've written, and I'll read it here, before I sign nothing." She looked at Elena. "You have been writing. Good. Keep writing. I want the time I was stopped, the time this search began, and the time it ends, and I want a printout of whatever your system produces today with my name on it. I read everything twice. Today I will read it three times."

From the sales floor, through the open door, came the sound of the store continuing — a register, a laugh, music at the volume of politeness. Harlan's radio crackled. He stepped to the doorway, listened, and his face did something complicated and then careful.

"Inventory's back," he said. "They've counted the white blouses on the floor and the stockroom."

Simone waited. Elena's pen stopped moving.

"The blouse," Harlan said, "is missing."

Caroline Whitmore did not lower her voice when the search produced nothing.

She stood just outside the security office, where customers could see her, and said an empty bag proved only that Simone Bennett was clever. She said it to Doug Harlan, to Elena Ruiz, and then, when neither of them answered in the way she wanted, to no one in particular, which was to say to everyone within hearing.

"She had time," Caroline said. "She was in that fitting room for ten minutes. She could have done anything."

Simone, still seated in the windowless office with Megan Foster and Elena beside her at her own request, listened without interrupting. Her handbag lay open on the desk where Harlan had left it. Her wallet, her phone, a folded list in her own handwriting, a pen. Nothing else had ever been in it. She did not reach to close it. She wanted the room to look, for as long as possible, exactly as it was.

"Then call the police," Caroline said. "If the store won't do its job, they can."

Elena spoke first. "Mrs. Whitmore, the police will ask the same questions I asked. What you saw, not what you believe."

"Then let them ask."

It was Harlan who made the call, because Castellano, reached by phone, would not countermand him. Elena noted the time on the pad she had carried since the second floor. Simone asked, quietly, that the note include who had requested the police, and Elena wrote that down as well.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part