Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The officers arrived twenty minutes later, through the main entrance, in uniform, in view of the Saturday crowd. Sergeant Karen Doyle was compact, graying, unhurried. Officer Ben Whitfield, younger, taller, carried the call log. Doyle took in the office, the open bag, the three women, and Harlan standing too close to the door, and her expression settled into something professional and closed.

She asked Simone if she was willing to speak. Simone said yes, and gave her account in order: arrival, the suit purchased, the three garments taken into fitting room four, the blouse tried on and left on the hook, the two garments carried out. Doyle wrote without looking up. When Simone finished, Doyle asked the same three questions Elena had asked Caroline on the floor, and Caroline, called in from the corridor, answered them again.

No, she had not seen Simone conceal the garment. No, she had not seen her place it in her bag. No, she had not seen her leave the fitting room carrying anything other than the two garments.

"But she went in with three," Caroline said.

"That part we know, ma'am," Doyle said.

Whitfield was sent to review the cameras with Harlan. The fitting-room corridor was covered by a single camera mounted high at the far end, and its angle compressed distance. On the monitor, figures entered the frame smaller than they were, garments over arms reduced to shapes and colors. Whitfield ran the sequence twice. Simone entering with what appeared to be three items. Simone leaving with two. After that, the frame held only the corridor, empty, for a long stretch, and the recording they were given stopped and restarted in a way that made the later minutes hard to place. Nobody, in that first viewing, saw Rosa Jimenez. The angle and the gap were noted as a problem to be resolved, not as evidence of anything.

It was enough, and it was not enough, and Doyle was careful about the difference.

Doyle asked for the inventory sheet before she would say anything further. Harlan produced it — a single line, a style number, the word missing in an associate's hurried hand. She asked when the count had been done, and by whom, and whether the rooms had been checked before it was written down. Harlan's answers rearranged themselves as he gave them. The count, it emerged, had been taken from the log alone. No one had yet searched the stock corridor. Doyle set the sheet down where everyone could see it.

"There is no evidence of a theft," she said, back in the office. "There is a missing item on a first count, and a complainant who did not witness a concealment. That is not probable cause. We are not making an arrest."

Caroline's face changed then, not with doubt but with the particular anger of a woman unused to being refused by institutions she considered hers. "So she just walks out."

"Yes, ma'am," Doyle said. "She does."

Simone stood. She closed her own bag, slowly, buckle by buckle. She asked Doyle for her name and badge number and Whitfield's, and for the incident number, and wrote them beneath Elena's notes on a sheet Elena tore from her pad without being asked. She thanked Megan, who looked as if she might cry and was determined not to. She did not thank Harlan.

She carried the blue dress and the burgundy gown, both still on their hangers in their bag, through the second floor and past the registers where she had been stopped. People made room for her in the way people do when they have watched something and are not sure whether to be ashamed of having watched it. A woman near the escalator held up a phone, then lowered it, too late to matter. Simone kept her eyes ahead and counted nothing.

Outside, the afternoon had gone thin and gold. Formally, she was free. She had been free, legally, the whole time, and she understood, standing on the pavement while a stranger's photograph of her detention was already moving through Caroline Whitmore's social circle, that the law's conclusion and the afternoon's conclusion were not the same thing.

The drive home took nineteen minutes, and Simone used none of them the way she usually did. Ordinarily she would have dictated notes for Monday, returned the foundation's calls in order of urgency, reviewed in her head the week she had already reviewed at five-fifteen that morning. Instead she drove with both hands where they belonged and thought about the hook inside fitting room four, and about how a thing could be exactly where she had left it and still not be found by people who had decided, in advance, where it must have gone.

Maya was in the kitchen when she came in, standing at the counter with a glass of water, homework spread where homework was not supposed to be. She looked up with the speech she had clearly been saving.

"Tell me you got it. Tell me the blue dress actually—" Then she stopped. Seventeen years of reading one face is its own education. "Mom. What happened."

Simone set the garment bag down over the back of a chair, carefully, the way she had carried it all afternoon. "Sit down," she said. "I'll tell you exactly, and I'll tell you in order."

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part