Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Ms. Foster knew Dr. Bennett's name because Dr. Bennett was a regular customer whom she had helped before. Is that a fair summary?"

"Yes."

"Is a sales associate knowing a regular customer's name evidence that a store has fabricated an inventory recovery?"

"No."

"Did you have any document? Any communication from any store employee? Any witness?"

"No."

"Then let me show you what the store's cameras recorded." A printed timeline was placed on the table, and a monitor was turned so Caroline could see it. The images were unremarkable, which was what made them unanswerable: a woman entering a fitting-room corridor carrying three garments; the same woman leaving carrying two; and then, twenty minutes later, in a stock corridor, Rosa Jimenez carrying a white blouse toward a rolling rack — at a minute when, on a third camera, Simone Bennett was still standing in the security office with her bag open on the desk.

Adrienne did not narrate. She let the timestamps do it, one after another, until the sequence closed like a door.

"At the time Ms. Jimenez was carrying that blouse, where was Dr. Bennett?"

"Detained," Caroline said. Her voice had gone thin. "She was detained."

"Could Dr. Bennett have placed that blouse on that rack?"

"No."

"Could anyone acting on Dr. Bennett's behalf have done so, to your knowledge?"

"No."

Caroline looked down at her folded hands and understood, in the way a deposition makes understanding unavoidable — under oath, on a record, with her own answers accumulating behind her — that she had never had anything. She had had a feeling about a woman she did not know, ten minutes of watching from twenty feet away, and a certainty so complete she had never examined it, because certainty like hers had never required examination. It had always simply been accepted. By sales associates. By managers, until Elena Ruiz. By her.

Her counsel asked for a break. In the hallway Caroline stood by a water cooler and did not drink. "She never raised her voice," she said, of Adrienne, as if that were the surprising part.

"She doesn't need to," her counsel said.

When they resumed, Adrienne asked only a few more questions, each gentle and exact, and Caroline answered truthfully. She had not seen a theft. She had had no source for the cover-up claim. She had made it anyway, publicly, after being offered the chance to apologize privately, about a woman whose name she had not known while raising money for that woman's foundation.

The deposition ended at 3:17 p.m. Walking to the elevator, Caroline said to her counsel, "I need to call Richard," and her counsel said only, "Yes. I think that's right."

Doug Harlan gave his deposition in the same building, a week later, wearing a jacket that still carried the shape of a uniform.

He answered in the clipped cadence of a man accustomed to reports. He had received a call from the general manager. A valued customer had reported a suspected theft. He had ordered the stop near the second-floor escalator, in view of the floor, because in his judgment a public stop discouraged flight. He had authorized the bag search.

"Did you review the fitting-room cameras before ordering the stop?" Adrienne asked.

"No. The inventory report indicated a missing garment."

"The inventory report came after the stop, Mr. Harlan. Let me ask again, in sequence. Before the stop: had any employee seen Dr. Bennett conceal anything?"

"No."

"Had Ms. Ruiz recommended a camera review first?"

"She had made a recommendation."

"She had objected, in writing, to a detention and search on the basis available. I am showing you her note." Adrienne slid it across. "Did you read it before you ordered the stop?"

Harlan looked at the page longer than reading required. "Castellano told me the decision had been made."

"So the decision to disregard a written objection by the floor manager was made by Mr. Castellano, and executed by you, without a camera review, without an observation of concealment, and on the word of a customer who had answered no to three direct questions from that same manager. Is any part of that inaccurate?"

His counsel conferred with him in a whisper. "That's — the summary omits the context," Harlan said. "The customer was a significant client. There was concern about how it would look if we dismissed her."

"How it would look," Adrienne said. "Thank you."

Robert Castellano, deposed the following day, supplied the context Harlan had reached for, and it did not help either of them. He described the Whitmore account in figures and his fear that a complaint from Caroline would cost the store its most visible client relationship and him his position. He confirmed that Elena had objected in writing, that he had read it, and that he had authorized Harlan regardless. Asked whether he would do so under the new policy, he said, "It wouldn't be permitted." Asked whether it should have been permitted under the old one, he was quiet for a long time before he said, "No. It should not have been."

Elena Ruiz testified on a Thursday, in the measured sentences of a woman who wrote notes for a living. She walked the record through her three questions and Caroline's three answers. She described recommending an inventory check and a camera review. She described being overruled. She was asked whether she had, at any point, believed Dr. Bennett had taken the blouse.

"At no point," Elena said. "I had no information that she had. I still have no information that she had, because she did not."

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

30 Part