Megan Foster, twenty-six, glanced up. She had worked the second floor for three years, long enough to know Mrs. Whitmore's face and to know what the Whitmore account meant to the people upstairs, though she had never once needed to be told. "Which woman, Mrs. Whitmore?"
"The one by the evening dresses. The charcoal coat." Caroline kept her voice low and reasonable. "I saw her put something near her bag. Just now. I thought someone should know."
Megan followed the direction of the look. Across the department, Simone Bennett was holding a blue dress up against the light from the windows, examining the shoulder seam with the particular frown of a person who has found a loose thread and is deciding what it means.
Megan knew that frown. She had helped Dr. Bennett before — twice that she could recall, once with a coat for a conference in Chicago and once with gifts, methodically chosen, for her foundation's staff at Christmas. On the second occasion Dr. Bennett had asked Megan's name, used it when she came back to the counter an hour later, and waited without impatience while a new trainee fumbled with the gift boxes. Megan had noticed because Mrs. Whitmore, and customers like her, often spoke to associates the way they spoke to furniture that could be instructed. Dr. Bennett was the kind of customer associates remembered because she was easy in the way demanding people rarely are: she knew what questions she was asking, she listened to the answers, and she said thank you to whoever had carried things.
Megan also knew what it cost an associate to contradict a client of Mrs. Whitmore's standing — the Whitmore name appeared on the Monday reports with a small star beside it. She felt the weight of that star now, and she answered anyway.
"That's Dr. Bennett," Megan said. "She's a regular customer. I've helped her before."
Caroline received this the way she received corrections generally, with a small, settled smile that suggested the correction had been noted and set gently aside. "I'm sure she may be. I'm only telling you what I saw. She put something right near her bag."
"Customers generally do that while shopping," Megan said, keeping her tone helpful and ordinary, because the older woman selecting cashmere was still within earshot and because it was, simply, true. "When they're checking sizes, or looking at a lining. Did you actually see her put merchandise inside her bag?"
There was a pause of perhaps two seconds.
"Not exactly," Caroline said. "But I know what I was watching."
Megan looked again at Simone, who had now draped the blue dress over her arm and was moving, unhurried, toward the burgundy gowns at the end of the next rack. Nothing in the scene resembled anything other than shopping. Megan had been trained — and more than trained, she had absorbed the store's deepest instinct — that suspicion was not an observation, and she felt, distinctly, that she was being asked to treat one as the other.
"I'll be on the floor," she said. "If there's anything specific you see, you can come and get me."
It was a polite ending and Megan intended it as one. She turned back to the older woman and the two grays, holding one up and then the other, and the small transaction of ordinary commerce resumed. She did not radio anyone. She did not follow Dr. Bennett with her eyes. In her judgment, there was nothing to report, and she went on with her work in the belief that the exchange was over.
It was not over, because Caroline Whitmore did not experience being unconvinced as a reason to stop being certain. If anything, Megan's calm struck her as a failure of vigilance — a young woman not wanting trouble, not wanting to offend a customer, perhaps not wanting to accuse someone she had served before. Caroline understood that failing. She had seen it on committees. People avoided unpleasant conclusions until the conclusions became unavoidable, and then they looked to someone like her, who had been willing to say the thing early, to tell them what to do next.
She considered asking for a manager at once, and decided against it, not from doubt but from method. A manager would ask what she had seen, precisely, and her answer had just been shown to sound thin in another person's hearing. She would watch a little longer, and gather the sort of detail that could not be talked away. The decision felt, as her decisions generally felt, like patience.
She would not be unhelpful about it. She took up a position near the scarves, where she could see the evening wear department without standing in anyone's way, and she watched Dr. Bennett — she used the title in her thoughts now with a slight, skeptical emphasis — take a burgundy gown from the rack and hold it up beside the blue dress, comparing, in the unhurried manner of a woman with all afternoon.
Ten minutes passed this way. Caroline did not count them. She would have said, if asked, that she had merely remained alert, which is what a responsible person does when a younger person declines to.
Simone had not intended to take three garments into the fitting room, but by the logic of shopping, three was the honest number.
The blue dress was the mission. The burgundy gown was the question she was asking herself on Maya's behalf and, if she was truthful, partly on her own: she would need something for next Saturday too, and the gown's color was the deep, unsweetened red she liked, and trying it beside the dress would tell her whether the two could exist in the same photographs without quarreling. And then, passing the blouses on her way — she told herself it was only because she was passing — she had taken a white blouse from the rack, the same cut as the one under the suit jacket she had just bought, because a spare of a thing that worked was not extravagance. It was planning.