I answered every complaint politely. I wrote short, careful letters back, thanking the board for bringing the matter to my attention, confirming that the items had been removed, the towels folded, the equipment screened, the noise addressed. I kept copies of everything in the kitchen drawer, in a folder I had started the week the noodles were cited, and the folder grew thicker, and every time I added a letter I felt a little more like a tenant in my own house and a little less like a homeowner. I blamed myself, because that was what I did. I told myself I should have brought the toys in, that I should have dried the towels inside, that Daniel should have put the bucket away, that Emma should have laughed more quietly, and each time I said it I believed it a little less and a little more at the same time, which is a strange way to feel, but it is how it was. I was new. I was trying to fit in. I thought if I was careful enough, and polite enough, and quick enough to fix whatever was wrong, the letters would stop.
They did not stop. They got stranger.
Daniel said it first, on a Sunday evening, when we were sitting on the patio after the kids were in bed, and the pool was still and blue in the dusk, and the yard smelled like cut grass and chlorine. He said Nora wanted control. He did not say it angrily. He said it the way he said most true things, plainly, as if he were reading a label. He said she wanted to decide what our yard looked like and what our daughter sounded like and where our bucket sat, and she wanted it because deciding things was what she did, and our pool was simply the nearest thing to decide about. I said she was lonely. I said it because I believed it, or because I wanted to believe it, because lonely was a kinder explanation than the other one, and I had spent the whole spring watching Nora at her fence with her tea and her lavender hand cream and her banana muffins, and I had convinced myself that the woman who brought muffins to a new neighbor could not also be the woman who wrote letters about a child's laughter. Daniel looked at me for a moment, and then he smiled, a small, tired smile, and he said that lonely people did not get to terrorize pool noodles. I laughed, because it was funny, and because it was true, and because I needed it to be funny. But later, lying in bed, I thought about it again, and I thought about the way Nora stood at the fence and watched our yard the way a person watches a television, and I thought about the way her letters arrived so quickly after things happened, as if she had been standing at her window with a notebook, and I felt a coldness settle in my stomach that had nothing to do with being funny.
The next complaint was not about something you could see. It was about something you could smell, except there was nothing to smell. The HOA had received a report, the letter said, that our pool water had an unusual odor. I read the sentence twice, and then I walked out to the pool and stood at the edge and leaned down and smelled the water, which smelled like water, like chlorine and summer and nothing else, and I dipped a test strip in and watched the colors come up, and they were normal, every one of them, exactly where they were supposed to be. The water was clear. I could see the drain at the bottom, clean and white, and I could see the pale blue tiles, and there was no cloudiness, no film, no smell. I took photographs of the water, and of the test strip beside the color chart, and of the filter gauge, and I sent them to the board with a short note saying the water tested normal and there was no odor, and asking if they would like me to have the water tested professionally. I never got a reply. Not a word. The silence was worse than a letter, because a letter at least told you what someone thought, and silence told you nothing, and nothing left room for everything.