That evening, Daniel came home and found the basket on the counter, and he took a muffin and ate it standing up, the way he eats everything when he has just come in from work, and he said it was good, and I said yes, it was good, and neither of us said anything about the woman who had brought it. The children ate two each, with milk, sitting at the kitchen table with their hair still wet from the pool, and Emma said the muffins tasted like bananas and sunshine, which is the kind of thing a four-year-old says when she is happy, and Miles said they were almost as good as the ones from the bakery near our old house, which was high praise coming from him, because he does not give praise easily. I watched them eat, and I thought about the yellow cellophane and the lavender hand cream and the way Nora had looked toward the pool, and I told myself to stop thinking about it, that a basket of muffins was just a basket of muffins, and that I was reading too much into a visit from a neighbor who was only doing what neighbors in Ashford Creek did. But I kept the cellophane. I folded it up and put it in a drawer, and I do not know why I did that, except that I have always kept things, receipts and forms and lab results and now, apparently, yellow cellophane, because keeping things is what I do when I do not yet know what they mean. I would learn what they meant soon enough. For now, though, the muffins were gone by morning, and the children were in the pool by afternoon, and the house smelled faintly of bananas, and I let myself believe that was all there was to it.
The first weeks settled into a routine, and the routine was good, and my hope was quiet and stubborn, the way hope gets when you have had to fight for it. I would sit by the pool in the afternoons, with my book open on my lap, and I would watch Miles cannonball and Emma rule the deep end from the third step, and I would think, this is normal. This is what I wanted. This is what we moved here for. And I would let myself believe, for a little while, that normal was something you could hold on to, that it would stay, that it would not slip away the way it had slipped away the year before, when Miles got sick and the waiting began. I did not know then that the complaints were coming, or that the itching would start, or that a video and an inspector were waiting just around the corner of the summer. I did not know any of that yet. All I knew was that my children were in the water, and the sun was on the deck, and the house, with its faded paint and its leaning fence and its cracked pool deck and its dishwasher from 1998, was ours, and for the first time in a long time, I let myself hope that it would stay that way.
The first complaint came on a Tuesday, tucked into our mailbox in one of those crisp white envelopes the HOA used for everything, the kind with the little return address printed in the corner in navy ink, and I remember standing in the driveway with the mail in my hand and thinking that it could not possibly be about anything serious, because nothing serious had happened. It was about the pool noodles. Three foam noodles and the small turtle float Emma loved, the one with the chipped green shell she had named in the spring, left overnight near the shallow end because Miles had been too tired to carry them in and I had been too tired to notice. The letter called it visible recreational clutter, and it said the items had been observed from the street, which was not quite true, because you could not see the shallow end from the street unless you stood on tiptoe at the side gate and leaned, but I did not argue with a letter. I folded it and put it in the kitchen drawer where I kept the other HOA papers, and I went out to the pool and carried the noodles and the turtle float into the garage myself, and I stacked them neatly against the wall, and I told myself that this was fine, that this was how neighborhoods worked, that a new family learned the rules by bumping into them gently, one small letter at a time.