Nora was still sitting on the patio chair, silent, staring at the fence, and every so often Deputy Collins would look over at her, just to make sure she was still there, just to make sure she was not going anywhere, and every so often Nora would shift in the chair, or cross her arms a different way, or look at her own house, as if she were calculating something, as if she were trying to figure out how much trouble she was in and whether there was still a way out of it. There was not. I could see it in her face, even when she tried to hide it. She knew the bottle was in the trash can. She knew Claire had filmed it. She knew the video was on a phone and on paper, in screenshots, in a folder, in more than one place. She knew, and she sat there in silence, because silence was the only thing she had left.
When the bottle was finally brought out, wrapped in tissue, held carefully in gloved hands, I felt my knees go weak, and Daniel put his arm around me, and Claire put her hand on my back, and I looked at that small bottle, and I thought about the way it had looked on the video, in Nora's hand, tipped over the water, the dark liquid pouring out, and I thought about Miles begging to swim, and Emma in her pink goggles, and the way their skin had felt like fire ants, and I thought about how close we had come to never knowing, how close we had come to draining the pool and paying the fine and believing it was our fault, and I was grateful, so grateful, to my sister, for standing in the kitchen with her phone up, for filming when she thought she saw the gate move, for keeping the video, for printing the screenshots, for driving over in twelve minutes, pale and shaking, with the truth in her hands.
They taped off the pool. Yellow tape, strung between the fence posts, around the patio, around the water, with a sign that said not to enter, not to swim, not to touch. And I stood there looking at it, at the blue water behind the yellow tape, at the pool that had been the center of our summer, the place where my children had laughed and played, and I thought about how strange it was, how a place could look so beautiful and be so poisoned at the same time, how the water could be so still and so clear and still be full of something that had made my children cry.
Miles came out onto the patio, very quietly, and he stood beside me, and he looked at the taped-off pool, and he looked up at me, and he said, "Mom? Was it my fault? For begging to swim?"
I knelt down so I was at his level, and I put my hands on his shoulders, and I looked him in the eyes, and I said, "No. No, baby. This was not your fault."
He nodded, but he did not look convinced, not yet, and then he said, "Did Mrs. Whitcomb do it?"
I hesitated. Just for a second. Just long enough to think about whether I should tell him, whether a seven-year-old needed to know that the woman next door had poured poison into his pool on purpose. And then I thought about the way he had asked, and the way he deserved an honest answer, and I said, "Yes."
"Why?" he said.
"I don't know," I said, and my voice caught, just a little, because I really did not know, because there was no reason good enough, no reason that made any sense at all. "Because she made a very wrong choice."
He nodded again, slowly, and he leaned against me, and I held him, and Emma came out onto the patio too, in her pajamas, her pink goggles still hanging around her neck, and she looked at the taped-off pool, and she looked at Nora's house, and she whispered, "Can she come back?"
Daniel answered first. He did not hesitate. He did not soften it. He just said, "No."