We fell into a routine, the kind of routine that feels like a gift when you have spent a year without one. Mornings, slow and easy, cereal at the kitchen table, the children in their swimsuits before they had even finished eating. Afternoons in the pool, the water warm by two o'clock, the sun high and white over the fence. Evenings, Daniel home from work, the grill going, the smell of burgers and cut grass, the children tired and pink-cheeked and happy in the way that only comes from a day spent entirely outside. I would sit on the deck in the evening, after the children were in bed, with a glass of iced tea, and I would listen to the crickets and the far-off sound of a lawnmower and the water in the pool settling after a day of splashing, and I would think, this is it. This is the summer I wanted. This is normal. And I would go inside and check on the children, and Miles would be asleep with his arms thrown over his head, and Emma would be asleep with her goggles still on the nightstand, and I would stand in the doorway and feel grateful in a way that made my throat tight, because gratitude, after a year like the one we had had, is not a light feeling. It is heavy and full and it sits in your chest and it makes you want to cry and laugh at the same time.
I did not know, in those first weeks, that Nora was also watching. I did not know that while I was sitting by the steps with my unread book, watching my children, someone else was watching us too, from behind a curtain, from a window, from a yard next door. I did not know that the blue house with the white shutters and the flower boxes lined up like they had been measured with a ruler was not just a pretty house, but a vantage point. I did not know that the woman who lived there kept a notebook, or that she photographed things, or that she knew our names before we had even finished unpacking. I was too busy being grateful to notice. I was too busy watching Miles and Emma to watch the woman next door. And that, I think, is the way it always starts. You are looking at the thing you love, and you do not see the thing that is looking back.
Nora came three days after we moved in. I remember the number because it felt too soon, and because I have always remembered the small things that felt wrong, even when I could not say why they felt wrong. Three days. We had not finished unpacking. There were still boxes in the hallway. The children were in the backyard, in the pool, because that was where they spent every afternoon, and I was in the kitchen, trying to find the box with the plates in it, when I heard one knock on the front door. One knock. Not two, not a friendly rattle, just one sharp knock, and then, before I could even wipe my hands on a dish towel and walk to the door, the screen door opened. She opened it herself. She did not wait for me to answer. She just opened the screen door and stepped into my hallway as if she had been invited, as if the house were already hers to enter, and she stood there holding a basket of banana muffins wrapped in yellow cellophane, smiling the way people smile when they have already decided what they think of you.
"Welcome," she said. "Nora Whitcomb. Next door." She said it the way a person introduces themselves at a meeting, with her full name, as if her name were a title. She was sixty-four, I would learn later, a widow, and she looked like the kind of woman who had always been put together, her hair neat, her clothes pressed, her hands smooth with lavender hand cream, which I could smell from where I stood, a soft, sweet smell that seemed out of place in a hallway full of boxes. "I know," she said, before I could say anything. "The board sends new resident names." She said it casually, as if it were the most natural thing in the world that a board would send her our names, as if we were a package that had been delivered and she had signed for it.
I thanked her for the muffins. I tried to be polite. I have always tried to be polite, even when something feels wrong, because my mother taught me that politeness costs nothing, and because I was new, and because I did not want to start a fight with my neighbor on the third day in a new house. I took the basket. The cellophane crinkled in my hands. The muffins smelled warm and sweet, and I thought, for a moment, that maybe I was wrong, that maybe she was just a friendly neighbor bringing a welcome gift, the way neighbors do in stories and in old movies. But then she looked past me, toward the back of the house, toward the pool, and her smile changed, just a little, the way a smile changes when the person wearing it is no longer smiling at you but at something they have already decided about you.