By noon I had eight bags sorted and photographed and re-bagged with blue tape labels: EVIDENCE 1 through EVIDENCE 8. My back ached. The gloves had a tear at the left thumb. The kitchen smelled like a dumpster behind a restaurant.
I sat on the floor with my notebook and wrote down what I knew, because that was what I did for clients when their books were a mess — you wrote down what you knew, and the shape of what you didn't know started to show itself.
What I knew: someone had put at least eight bags of trash, plus loose garbage, into my locked house while I was gone. The trash belonged to a household at 12 Alder Street — the names Marcus Bell, Priya Sharma, Denise Marsh. It was a cleanout: clothes, moving boxes, old mail, the kind of thing you throw away when you move or when someone dies or when you just decide to start over.
What I didn't know: everything else.
I called Kate. "I need you to come over," I said. "And bring your own gloves. The yellow kind."
"Julia." Kate's voice had that nurse's calm that meant she was deciding how worried to be. "What happened?"
"Someone's been putting trash in my house. It's not mine. It's — it's a whole other family's trash, Kate. There's mail. There's a birthday card."
There was a pause. "I'm coming," she said. "Don't touch anything else until I get there."
"I already touched everything," I said. "I photographed everything. I'm bagging it as evidence."
"Of course you are," Kate said. "You're the only person I know who would catalog a crime scene before calling the police. I'm bringing sandwiches."
She arrived an hour later with sandwiches and a second pair of gloves and stood in my kitchen doorway looking at the taped bags lined up against the wall.
"Jesus, Julia."
"Twelve Alder Street," I said. "Do you know where that is?"
"Two streets over. Behind the elementary school." Kate picked up my notebook and read it. "You think someone's dumping here on purpose."
"I think someone carried eight bags of another family's garbage into my house, through a locked door, three times in two months." I unwrapped my sandwich. My hands were shaking, and I was angry at them for it. "That's not an accident, Kate. That's a decision somebody made."
Chapter 11: Other People's Trash
Kate stayed until dark. We went through the remaining bags together, and the picture got worse — or clearer, which felt like the same thing.
Bag nine: moving boxes, broken down, the tape still on them, labeled in thick marker: KITCHEN — FRAGILE, and BEDROOM — MISC. Someone had packed a whole apartment and then thrown the packing away.
Bag ten: a tangle of old phone chargers, a cracked tablet with a shattered screen, a remote control with no batteries. A stack of children's drawings, the crayon colors still bright. I photographed each one before re-bagging them. A house with a red door. A dog with too many legs. A woman with yellow hair holding the hand of a smaller figure. I didn't know why those drawings made my throat tight, but they did.
"They moved," Kate said quietly, looking at the drawings. "Somebody moved out of 12 Alder Street and threw everything away."
"Or somebody died," I said. "Or somebody got evicted. We don't know."
"We know it's not yours," Kate said. "That's the part that matters."
In bag eleven I found a lease termination notice, folded in quarters, for 12 Alder Street, dated the end of January. The tenant names matched the mail: Bell and Nair. So they had moved out. Someone had cleaned out the apartment — or been hired to clean it out — and the trash had ended up in my hallway instead of wherever it was supposed to go.
"Where is trash supposed to go?" I asked Kate.
"The dump. The county landfill, out past the highway." She was writing in my notebook now, in her neat nurse's handwriting. "You pay by weight. It's not cheap."
"How not cheap?"
"I don't know. Enough that somebody might not want to pay it."
We looked at each other. The kitchen was quiet except for the refrigerator humming.
"You're thinking what I'm thinking," Kate said.
"I'm thinking I need to know who hauls trash in this town," I said.
Bag twelve was the last one, and it was the one that changed everything. It was smaller than the others, a kitchen bag knotted at the top, and it had been tucked behind the water heater in the laundry nook — like someone had hidden it, or like it had fallen and rolled there. Inside, under a layer of coffee grounds and eggshells, was a crumpled piece of paper.
I smoothed it out on the counter. It was an invoice.
CLEANSLATE HAULING, it said across the top, in a cheerful green logo with a little cartoon truck. Below that: an address in Willow Creek, a phone number. And below that, an itemized bill: JUNK REMOVAL — 1 LOAD, and LANDFILL DISPOSAL FEE, and a total at the bottom.